Under the low-fragrance default, QV leads at 86.4; with scent preference removed, Dove leads at 87.7. Aveeno and Ceradan are fragrance-free-labelled alternatives. Fragranced Bioderma is the highest-scoring shower oil at its quoted import price before shipping; Yukazan 55/75 tie at 75.4. Close scores and scent preferences can change the choice. [128, 134, 124, 125, 122, 171, 60, 158]
Scores are rounded; exact ties share ranks and close estimates are weak distinctions. Format follows the marketed label; unit cost is per labelled amount, not per shower, and bottle/formula qualifications remain below. The four named cleansing/foaming oil entries are excluded from this field by the requested scope. [149, 122, 171, 125, 120, 52, 127] Plant Origins uses a Member offer; verify eligibility and current checkout price. [168] Design tiers express low-fragrance fit, not measured cleansing. [177]
Compare side by side. Scroll across for more columns.
Best shower oils and body washes in Malaysia — comparison
Base price uses 1.25 kg; the checked 500 g alternative and its reference-price sensitivity are shown separately. [125, 71]
Assessment
A useful starting point for a shopper seeking a fragrance-free-labelled everyday wash. The Malay…
A useful starting point for a shopper seeking a fragrance-free-labelled everyday wash. The Malaysian brand and retailer ingredient panels align for this size, and the brand discloses glycerin concentration. It is sold by mass: its cost per gram cannot be treated as a cost per millilitre without density evidence. [115, 71, 84]
A useful starting point for a shopper seeking a fragrance-free-labelled everyday wash. The Malaysian brand and retailer ingredient panels align for this size, and the brand discloses glycerin concentration. It is sold by mass: its cost per gram cannot be treated as a cost per millilitre without density evidence. [115, 71, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [128]
Local oat/SLES formula; Watsons also lists Quaternium-15. [22, 42, 59, 86]
Assessment
An oat-containing, fragrance-free-labelled everyday option with a Malaysian large-bottle offer.…
An oat-containing, fragrance-free-labelled everyday option with a Malaysian large-bottle offer. The checked local list contains SLES and Quaternium-15; check the supplied panel if avoiding those ingredients, and do not substitute the US sulfate-free recipe. No comparable body-wash trial supports an advantage over QV or Ceradan. [22, 42, 59, 84, 86]
An oat-containing, fragrance-free-labelled everyday option with a Malaysian large-bottle offer. The checked local list contains SLES and Quaternium-15; check the supplied panel if avoiding those ingredients, and do not substitute the US sulfate-free recipe. No comparable body-wash trial supports an advantage over QV or Ceradan. [22, 42, 59, 84, 86]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [129]
Watsons 550 ml title/list assessed conditionally; another retailer’s 500 ml Beauty Nourishing photo does not confirm the bottle. [121, 65]
Assessment
Joint lowest listed cost per volume among the compared millilitre-labelled offers. This Malaysia…
Joint lowest listed cost per volume among the compared millilitre-labelled offers. This Malaysian variant contains perfume and SLES. Choose it for budget and your preferred feel/scent, rather than a claim that it beats Sensitive Skin in gentleness; no matched head-to-head result was recovered. [21, 42, 65, 84]
Joint lowest listed cost per volume among the compared millilitre-labelled offers. This Malaysian variant contains perfume and SLES. Choose it for budget and your preferred feel/scent, rather than a claim that it beats Sensitive Skin in gentleness; no matched head-to-head result was recovered. [21, 42, 65, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [130]
Shares the lowest listed cost per volume in the compared millilitre-labelled field. The checked…
Shares the lowest listed cost per volume in the compared millilitre-labelled field. The checked Malaysian Sensitive Skin ingredient list includes perfume and SLES, so the name does not make it a fragrance-free choice. Keep it distinct from foreign Dove recipes and from Deeply Nourishing. [20, 42, 66, 84]
Shares the lowest listed cost per volume in the compared millilitre-labelled field. The checked Malaysian Sensitive Skin ingredient list includes perfume and SLES, so the name does not make it a fragrance-free choice. Keep it distinct from foreign Dove recipes and from Deeply Nourishing. [20, 42, 66, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [131]
Lipid-ratio marketing is not a comparative outcome. [25, 26, 42, 61]
Assessment
A fragrance-free-labelled body wash. The published ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid ratio is a fo…
A fragrance-free-labelled body wash. The published ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid ratio is a formula claim, not a measured advantage over competing cleansers. Its listed sodium trideceth sulphate also means SLS/SLES-free should not be expanded into all-sulfates-free. [25, 26, 42, 61, 84, 152]
A fragrance-free-labelled body wash. The published ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid ratio is a formula claim, not a measured advantage over competing cleansers. Its listed sodium trideceth sulphate also means SLS/SLES-free should not be expanded into all-sulfates-free. [25, 26, 42, 61, 84, 152]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [132]
France import; contains parfum; shipping is additional. [9, 10, 11, 60]
Assessment
A fragranced comfort option with a clearly identified French import offer. Bioderma publishes us…
A fragranced comfort option with a clearly identified French import offer. Bioderma publishes useful hydration-test details, but no recovered head-to-head trial establishes a clinical winner. The seller’s ingredient list includes parfum; it is not the fragrance-free default, and shipping changes the delivered cost. [9, 10, 11, 60, 84]
A fragranced comfort option with a clearly identified French import offer. Bioderma publishes useful hydration-test details, but no recovered head-to-head trial establishes a clinical winner. The seller’s ingredient list includes parfum; it is not the fragrance-free default, and shipping changes the delivered cost. [9, 10, 11, 60, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [134]
Fragrance-free label conflicts with retailer heliotropine panel; no fragrance-free scoring bonus. [120]
Assessment
A lower-priced local option whose Malaysian brand page calls it fragrance-free. AA Pharmacy’s in…
A lower-priced local option whose Malaysian brand page calls it fragrance-free. AA Pharmacy’s ingredient panel lists heliotropine, a sourced fragrance material, leaving a label/formula conflict for strict fragrance avoidance. Confirm the actual bottle instead of treating either page as a resolved formula match. [120, 27, 63, 84]
A lower-priced local option whose Malaysian brand page calls it fragrance-free. AA Pharmacy’s ingredient panel lists heliotropine, a sourced fragrance material, leaving a label/formula conflict for strict fragrance avoidance. Confirm the actual bottle instead of treating either page as a resolved formula match. [120, 27, 63, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [137]
Member offer; verify eligibility and checkout price, with RRP retained only as a hypothetical scenario. [168, 173]
Assessment
A fresh citrus option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/…
A fresh citrus option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [161, 169, 168, 174]
A fresh citrus option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [161, 169, 168, 174]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.3, conditional on primary formula and RM39.90 Member offer. [169, 167, 168]
Member offer; verify eligibility and checkout price, with RRP retained only as a hypothetical scenario. [168, 173]
Assessment
A herbal/wood option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/a…
A herbal/wood option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [162, 170, 168, 174]
A herbal/wood option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [162, 170, 168, 174]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.3, conditional on primary formula and RM39.90 Member offer. [170, 167, 168]
Advertised Bluebell; percentage meaning and relative performance unverified. [1, 57, 46, 76]
Assessment
Choose this official variant if the advertised Bluebell fragrance appeals. Its published list st…
Choose this official variant if the advertised Bluebell fragrance appeals. Its published list starts with water and includes olive oil, shea butter, SLES and ceramide. The percentage has no verified quantitative definition, and no matched outcome comparison shows it inferior to the higher-numbered oils. [1, 57, 46, 76, 84]
Choose this official variant if the advertised Bluebell fragrance appeals. Its published list starts with water and includes olive oil, shea butter, SLES and ceramide. The percentage has no verified quantitative definition, and no matched outcome comparison shows it inferior to the higher-numbered oils. [1, 57, 46, 76, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [139]
Fresh Fig official formula; Watsons’ similarly named listing differs. [2, 4, 57, 46, 77]
Assessment
The official Fresh Fig candidate for someone wanting Yukazan’s scented shower-oil experience. It…
The official Fresh Fig candidate for someone wanting Yukazan’s scented shower-oil experience. Its published butter/oil-led list includes SLES and ceramide, without proving total oil concentration. Watsons publishes a different scent and ingredient sequence for its similarly named listing; do not use that listing as a same-formula price comparison. [2, 4, 57, 46, 77, 84]
The official Fresh Fig candidate for someone wanting Yukazan’s scented shower-oil experience. Its published butter/oil-led list includes SLES and ceramide, without proving total oil concentration. Watsons publishes a different scent and ingredient sequence for its similarly named listing; do not use that listing as a same-formula price comparison. [2, 4, 57, 46, 77, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [140]
Contains parfum; manufacture claim is distinct from majority ownership. [18, 19, 73]
Assessment
The fragrance-led option to investigate for a yuzu/green-tea profile from a brand claiming Malay…
The fragrance-led option to investigate for a yuzu/green-tea profile from a brand claiming Malaysian manufacture. Its published list contains parfum and saccharide isomerate; the PENTAVITIN story does not provide a recovered finished-product superiority trial. A smaller official bottle offers a lower-cost scent trial. [18, 19, 73, 84]
The fragrance-led option to investigate for a yuzu/green-tea profile from a brand claiming Malaysian manufacture. Its published list contains parfum and saccharide isomerate; the PENTAVITIN story does not provide a recovered finished-product superiority trial. A smaller official bottle offers a lower-cost scent trial. [18, 19, 73, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [141]
Claim-based provisional assessment; full current INCI unknown. [23, 112]
Assessment
The separately identified fragrance version, at a lower one-bottle price than the ceramide versi…
The separately identified fragrance version, at a lower one-bottle price than the ceramide version. The current full ingredient panel was not recovered, and the historical Premium Goat Milk name is not proof of an unchanged formula. No matched trial demonstrates a cleansing or comfort disadvantage. [23, 46, 75, 84]
The separately identified fragrance version, at a lower one-bottle price than the ceramide version. The current full ingredient panel was not recovered, and the historical Premium Goat Milk name is not proof of an unchanged formula. No matched trial demonstrates a cleansing or comfort disadvantage. [23, 46, 75, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [142]
An additional pharmacy shower-oil option with an exact-size listing from the seller named Euceri…
An additional pharmacy shower-oil option with an exact-size listing from the seller named Eucerin Malaysia Official Store. The Malaysian brand page discusses fragranced and unperfumed versions without resolving the full ingredient panel of this offer. Check which version is supplied before choosing it for fragrance avoidance. [52, 67, 84]
An additional pharmacy shower-oil option with an exact-size listing from the seller named Eucerin Malaysia Official Store. The Malaysian brand page discusses fragranced and unperfumed versions without resolving the full ingredient panel of this offer. Check which version is supplied before choosing it for fragrance avoidance. [52, 67, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [143]
Smaller bottle; higher unit cost with no proved hydration upgrade. [3, 57, 79, 46, 78]
Assessment
A distinct warm-woody scent choice in a smaller bottle. At the same listed bottle price as the l…
A distinct warm-woody scent choice in a smaller bottle. At the same listed bottle price as the larger official 55/75 variants it costs more per volume, while the percentage does not establish better hydration. Its published list has a different surfactant system and no ceramide; buy it for an actual preference, not a numerical upgrade. [3, 57, 79, 46, 78, 84]
A distinct warm-woody scent choice in a smaller bottle. At the same listed bottle price as the larger official 55/75 variants it costs more per volume, while the percentage does not establish better hydration. Its published list has a different surfactant system and no ceramide; buy it for an actual preference, not a numerical upgrade. [3, 57, 79, 46, 78, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [144]
Claim-based design score; full INCI and fragrance-label conflict unresolved. [24, 112]
Assessment
A distinct ceramide-labelled goat’s-milk wash with an official offer. Its reference bottle simul…
A distinct ceramide-labelled goat’s-milk wash with an official offer. Its reference bottle simultaneously says fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented, so it cannot receive an unqualified scent-free recommendation. The full current ingredient panel and any advantage over the cheaper Fragrance variant remain unverified. [23, 24, 46, 74, 84]
A distinct ceramide-labelled goat’s-milk wash with an official offer. Its reference bottle simultaneously says fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented, so it cannot receive an unqualified scent-free recommendation. The full current ingredient panel and any advantage over the cheaper Fragrance variant remain unverified. [23, 24, 46, 74, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [145]
Almond/vanilla ritual premium; Malaysian formula match unverified. [109, 68]
Assessment
A scented oil-to-milky-foam ritual for shoppers who actively like the almond/vanilla profile. It…
A scented oil-to-milky-foam ritual for shoppers who actively like the almond/vanilla profile. Its official refill reduces the listed unit cost, but the premium does not establish a clinical performance advantage. The current Malaysian full ingredient panel was not recovered; a new packaging code is not a release date. [114, 17, 68, 84]
A scented oil-to-milky-foam ritual for shoppers who actively like the almond/vanilla profile. Its official refill reduces the listed unit cost, but the premium does not establish a clinical performance advantage. The current Malaysian full ingredient panel was not recovered; a new packaging code is not a release date. [114, 17, 68, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [146]
Exact 500 ml marketplace offer; no verified authorised-local-distribution claim. [32, 42, 70]
Assessment
A glycerin-led, oil-enriched wash for shoppers interested in its coconut/vanilla presentation. Z…
A glycerin-led, oil-enriched wash for shoppers interested in its coconut/vanilla presentation. ZALORA’s embedded exact-size offer now resolves the earlier ambiguity at a lower listed price than the preserved buying-service quote. No artificial fragrance is not proof of scentlessness or a measured value advantage. [32, 42, 70, 84]
A glycerin-led, oil-enriched wash for shoppers interested in its coconut/vanilla presentation. ZALORA’s embedded exact-size offer now resolves the earlier ambiguity at a lower listed price than the preserved buying-service quote. No artificial fragrance is not proof of scentlessness or a measured value advantage. [32, 42, 70, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [147]
Luxury perfume ritual price; not a demonstrated hydration premium. [110, 64]
Assessment
The luxury choice to investigate for the Do Son tuberose fragrance and oil-to-foam ritual. KENS…
The luxury choice to investigate for the Do Son tuberose fragrance and oil-to-foam ritual. KENS now supplies an exact Malaysian product page and offer. That does not identify a hotel amenity or establish superior cleansing/hydration, and a current US ingredient reference is recovered, but the supplied-bottle formula match remains unverified. [110][157, 64, 84]
The luxury choice to investigate for the Do Son tuberose fragrance and oil-to-foam ritual. KENS now supplies an exact Malaysian product page and offer. That does not identify a hotel amenity or establish superior cleansing/hydration, and a current US ingredient reference is recovered, but the supplied-bottle formula match remains unverified. [110][157, 64, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [148]
Base price uses 1.25 kg; the checked 500 g alternative and its reference-price sensitivity are shown separately. [125, 71]
Assessment
A useful starting point for a shopper seeking a fragrance-free-labelled everyday wash. The Malay…
A useful starting point for a shopper seeking a fragrance-free-labelled everyday wash. The Malaysian brand and retailer ingredient panels align for this size, and the brand discloses glycerin concentration. It is sold by mass: its cost per gram cannot be treated as a cost per millilitre without density evidence. [115, 71, 84]
A useful starting point for a shopper seeking a fragrance-free-labelled everyday wash. The Malaysian brand and retailer ingredient panels align for this size, and the brand discloses glycerin concentration. It is sold by mass: its cost per gram cannot be treated as a cost per millilitre without density evidence. [115, 71, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [128]
Local oat/SLES formula; Watsons also lists Quaternium-15. [22, 42, 59, 86]
Assessment
An oat-containing, fragrance-free-labelled everyday option with a Malaysian large-bottle offer.…
An oat-containing, fragrance-free-labelled everyday option with a Malaysian large-bottle offer. The checked local list contains SLES and Quaternium-15; check the supplied panel if avoiding those ingredients, and do not substitute the US sulfate-free recipe. No comparable body-wash trial supports an advantage over QV or Ceradan. [22, 42, 59, 84, 86]
An oat-containing, fragrance-free-labelled everyday option with a Malaysian large-bottle offer. The checked local list contains SLES and Quaternium-15; check the supplied panel if avoiding those ingredients, and do not substitute the US sulfate-free recipe. No comparable body-wash trial supports an advantage over QV or Ceradan. [22, 42, 59, 84, 86]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [129]
Watsons 550 ml title/list assessed conditionally; another retailer’s 500 ml Beauty Nourishing photo does not confirm the bottle. [121, 65]
Assessment
Joint lowest listed cost per volume among the compared millilitre-labelled offers. This Malaysia…
Joint lowest listed cost per volume among the compared millilitre-labelled offers. This Malaysian variant contains perfume and SLES. Choose it for budget and your preferred feel/scent, rather than a claim that it beats Sensitive Skin in gentleness; no matched head-to-head result was recovered. [21, 42, 65, 84]
Joint lowest listed cost per volume among the compared millilitre-labelled offers. This Malaysian variant contains perfume and SLES. Choose it for budget and your preferred feel/scent, rather than a claim that it beats Sensitive Skin in gentleness; no matched head-to-head result was recovered. [21, 42, 65, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [130]
Shares the lowest listed cost per volume in the compared millilitre-labelled field. The checked…
Shares the lowest listed cost per volume in the compared millilitre-labelled field. The checked Malaysian Sensitive Skin ingredient list includes perfume and SLES, so the name does not make it a fragrance-free choice. Keep it distinct from foreign Dove recipes and from Deeply Nourishing. [20, 42, 66, 84]
Shares the lowest listed cost per volume in the compared millilitre-labelled field. The checked Malaysian Sensitive Skin ingredient list includes perfume and SLES, so the name does not make it a fragrance-free choice. Keep it distinct from foreign Dove recipes and from Deeply Nourishing. [20, 42, 66, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [131]
Lipid-ratio marketing is not a comparative outcome. [25, 26, 42, 61]
Assessment
A fragrance-free-labelled body wash. The published ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid ratio is a fo…
A fragrance-free-labelled body wash. The published ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid ratio is a formula claim, not a measured advantage over competing cleansers. Its listed sodium trideceth sulphate also means SLS/SLES-free should not be expanded into all-sulfates-free. [25, 26, 42, 61, 84, 152]
A fragrance-free-labelled body wash. The published ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid ratio is a formula claim, not a measured advantage over competing cleansers. Its listed sodium trideceth sulphate also means SLS/SLES-free should not be expanded into all-sulfates-free. [25, 26, 42, 61, 84, 152]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [132]
France import; contains parfum; shipping is additional. [9, 10, 11, 60]
Assessment
A fragranced comfort option with a clearly identified French import offer. Bioderma publishes us…
A fragranced comfort option with a clearly identified French import offer. Bioderma publishes useful hydration-test details, but no recovered head-to-head trial establishes a clinical winner. The seller’s ingredient list includes parfum; it is not the fragrance-free default, and shipping changes the delivered cost. [9, 10, 11, 60, 84]
A fragranced comfort option with a clearly identified French import offer. Bioderma publishes useful hydration-test details, but no recovered head-to-head trial establishes a clinical winner. The seller’s ingredient list includes parfum; it is not the fragrance-free default, and shipping changes the delivered cost. [9, 10, 11, 60, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [134]
Fragrance-free label conflicts with retailer heliotropine panel; no fragrance-free scoring bonus. [120]
Assessment
A lower-priced local option whose Malaysian brand page calls it fragrance-free. AA Pharmacy’s in…
A lower-priced local option whose Malaysian brand page calls it fragrance-free. AA Pharmacy’s ingredient panel lists heliotropine, a sourced fragrance material, leaving a label/formula conflict for strict fragrance avoidance. Confirm the actual bottle instead of treating either page as a resolved formula match. [120, 27, 63, 84]
A lower-priced local option whose Malaysian brand page calls it fragrance-free. AA Pharmacy’s ingredient panel lists heliotropine, a sourced fragrance material, leaving a label/formula conflict for strict fragrance avoidance. Confirm the actual bottle instead of treating either page as a resolved formula match. [120, 27, 63, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [137]
Member offer; verify eligibility and checkout price, with RRP retained only as a hypothetical scenario. [168, 173]
Assessment
A fresh citrus option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/…
A fresh citrus option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [161, 169, 168, 174]
A fresh citrus option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [161, 169, 168, 174]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.3, conditional on primary formula and RM39.90 Member offer. [169, 167, 168]
Member offer; verify eligibility and checkout price, with RRP retained only as a hypothetical scenario. [168, 173]
Assessment
A herbal/wood option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/a…
A herbal/wood option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [162, 170, 168, 174]
A herbal/wood option within Spa / aromatic, with a published ordinary daily wash and glycerine/aloe conditioning design. The provisional score uses the current RM39.90 Member quote; verify eligibility and checkout price. Essential-oil scent and plant-extract count do not establish a hydration or tolerability advantage; supplied-batch equivalence remains unverified. [162, 170, 168, 174]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.3, conditional on primary formula and RM39.90 Member offer. [170, 167, 168]
Advertised Bluebell; percentage meaning and relative performance unverified. [1, 57, 46, 76]
Assessment
Choose this official variant if the advertised Bluebell fragrance appeals. Its published list st…
Choose this official variant if the advertised Bluebell fragrance appeals. Its published list starts with water and includes olive oil, shea butter, SLES and ceramide. The percentage has no verified quantitative definition, and no matched outcome comparison shows it inferior to the higher-numbered oils. [1, 57, 46, 76, 84]
Choose this official variant if the advertised Bluebell fragrance appeals. Its published list starts with water and includes olive oil, shea butter, SLES and ceramide. The percentage has no verified quantitative definition, and no matched outcome comparison shows it inferior to the higher-numbered oils. [1, 57, 46, 76, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [139]
Fresh Fig official formula; Watsons’ similarly named listing differs. [2, 4, 57, 46, 77]
Assessment
The official Fresh Fig candidate for someone wanting Yukazan’s scented shower-oil experience. It…
The official Fresh Fig candidate for someone wanting Yukazan’s scented shower-oil experience. Its published butter/oil-led list includes SLES and ceramide, without proving total oil concentration. Watsons publishes a different scent and ingredient sequence for its similarly named listing; do not use that listing as a same-formula price comparison. [2, 4, 57, 46, 77, 84]
The official Fresh Fig candidate for someone wanting Yukazan’s scented shower-oil experience. Its published butter/oil-led list includes SLES and ceramide, without proving total oil concentration. Watsons publishes a different scent and ingredient sequence for its similarly named listing; do not use that listing as a same-formula price comparison. [2, 4, 57, 46, 77, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [140]
Contains parfum; manufacture claim is distinct from majority ownership. [18, 19, 73]
Assessment
The fragrance-led option to investigate for a yuzu/green-tea profile from a brand claiming Malay…
The fragrance-led option to investigate for a yuzu/green-tea profile from a brand claiming Malaysian manufacture. Its published list contains parfum and saccharide isomerate; the PENTAVITIN story does not provide a recovered finished-product superiority trial. A smaller official bottle offers a lower-cost scent trial. [18, 19, 73, 84]
The fragrance-led option to investigate for a yuzu/green-tea profile from a brand claiming Malaysian manufacture. Its published list contains parfum and saccharide isomerate; the PENTAVITIN story does not provide a recovered finished-product superiority trial. A smaller official bottle offers a lower-cost scent trial. [18, 19, 73, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [141]
Claim-based provisional assessment; full current INCI unknown. [23, 112]
Assessment
The separately identified fragrance version, at a lower one-bottle price than the ceramide versi…
The separately identified fragrance version, at a lower one-bottle price than the ceramide version. The current full ingredient panel was not recovered, and the historical Premium Goat Milk name is not proof of an unchanged formula. No matched trial demonstrates a cleansing or comfort disadvantage. [23, 46, 75, 84]
The separately identified fragrance version, at a lower one-bottle price than the ceramide version. The current full ingredient panel was not recovered, and the historical Premium Goat Milk name is not proof of an unchanged formula. No matched trial demonstrates a cleansing or comfort disadvantage. [23, 46, 75, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [142]
An additional pharmacy shower-oil option with an exact-size listing from the seller named Euceri…
An additional pharmacy shower-oil option with an exact-size listing from the seller named Eucerin Malaysia Official Store. The Malaysian brand page discusses fragranced and unperfumed versions without resolving the full ingredient panel of this offer. Check which version is supplied before choosing it for fragrance avoidance. [52, 67, 84]
An additional pharmacy shower-oil option with an exact-size listing from the seller named Eucerin Malaysia Official Store. The Malaysian brand page discusses fragranced and unperfumed versions without resolving the full ingredient panel of this offer. Check which version is supplied before choosing it for fragrance avoidance. [52, 67, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [143]
Smaller bottle; higher unit cost with no proved hydration upgrade. [3, 57, 79, 46, 78]
Assessment
A distinct warm-woody scent choice in a smaller bottle. At the same listed bottle price as the l…
A distinct warm-woody scent choice in a smaller bottle. At the same listed bottle price as the larger official 55/75 variants it costs more per volume, while the percentage does not establish better hydration. Its published list has a different surfactant system and no ceramide; buy it for an actual preference, not a numerical upgrade. [3, 57, 79, 46, 78, 84]
A distinct warm-woody scent choice in a smaller bottle. At the same listed bottle price as the larger official 55/75 variants it costs more per volume, while the percentage does not establish better hydration. Its published list has a different surfactant system and no ceramide; buy it for an actual preference, not a numerical upgrade. [3, 57, 79, 46, 78, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [144]
Claim-based design score; full INCI and fragrance-label conflict unresolved. [24, 112]
Assessment
A distinct ceramide-labelled goat’s-milk wash with an official offer. Its reference bottle simul…
A distinct ceramide-labelled goat’s-milk wash with an official offer. Its reference bottle simultaneously says fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented, so it cannot receive an unqualified scent-free recommendation. The full current ingredient panel and any advantage over the cheaper Fragrance variant remain unverified. [23, 24, 46, 74, 84]
A distinct ceramide-labelled goat’s-milk wash with an official offer. Its reference bottle simultaneously says fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented, so it cannot receive an unqualified scent-free recommendation. The full current ingredient panel and any advantage over the cheaper Fragrance variant remain unverified. [23, 24, 46, 74, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [145]
Almond/vanilla ritual premium; Malaysian formula match unverified. [109, 68]
Assessment
A scented oil-to-milky-foam ritual for shoppers who actively like the almond/vanilla profile. It…
A scented oil-to-milky-foam ritual for shoppers who actively like the almond/vanilla profile. Its official refill reduces the listed unit cost, but the premium does not establish a clinical performance advantage. The current Malaysian full ingredient panel was not recovered; a new packaging code is not a release date. [114, 17, 68, 84]
A scented oil-to-milky-foam ritual for shoppers who actively like the almond/vanilla profile. Its official refill reduces the listed unit cost, but the premium does not establish a clinical performance advantage. The current Malaysian full ingredient panel was not recovered; a new packaging code is not a release date. [114, 17, 68, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [146]
Exact 500 ml marketplace offer; no verified authorised-local-distribution claim. [32, 42, 70]
Assessment
A glycerin-led, oil-enriched wash for shoppers interested in its coconut/vanilla presentation. Z…
A glycerin-led, oil-enriched wash for shoppers interested in its coconut/vanilla presentation. ZALORA’s embedded exact-size offer now resolves the earlier ambiguity at a lower listed price than the preserved buying-service quote. No artificial fragrance is not proof of scentlessness or a measured value advantage. [32, 42, 70, 84]
A glycerin-led, oil-enriched wash for shoppers interested in its coconut/vanilla presentation. ZALORA’s embedded exact-size offer now resolves the earlier ambiguity at a lower listed price than the preserved buying-service quote. No artificial fragrance is not proof of scentlessness or a measured value advantage. [32, 42, 70, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [147]
Luxury perfume ritual price; not a demonstrated hydration premium. [110, 64]
Assessment
The luxury choice to investigate for the Do Son tuberose fragrance and oil-to-foam ritual. KENS…
The luxury choice to investigate for the Do Son tuberose fragrance and oil-to-foam ritual. KENS now supplies an exact Malaysian product page and offer. That does not identify a hotel amenity or establish superior cleansing/hydration, and a current US ingredient reference is recovered, but the supplied-bottle formula match remains unverified. [110][157, 64, 84]
The luxury choice to investigate for the Do Son tuberose fragrance and oil-to-foam ritual. KENS now supplies an exact Malaysian product page and offer. That does not identify a hotel amenity or establish superior cleansing/hydration, and a current US ingredient reference is recovered, but the supplied-bottle formula match remains unverified. [110][157, 64, 84]
Evidence
Provisional Refer author assessment SHOWER-OIL-2.2; full breakdown and assumptions in the scoring section. [148]
Choose by need as well as the score; strict fragrance avoidance and scent enjoyment can change the right purchase. [127, 171]
Choose by need
Your priority
Consider
Quoted bottle
Before buying
Lowest listed cost per volume
Dove Sensitive Skin / Deeply Nourishing
RM15.90 · 550 ml
Both checked Malaysian formulas contain perfume; choose on your own preferred feel/scent. [20, 21, 65, 66, 116]
More detail for Lowest listed cost per volume
Before buying
Both checked Malaysian formulas contain perfume; choose on your own preferred feel/scent. [20, 21, 65, 66, 116]
Simple fragrance-free-labelled wash
QV Gentle Wash
RM91.12 · 1.25 kg
Aligned local panels; priced by mass, with a newly checked 500 g alternative shown separately. [125][115, 71, 116, 84, 125]
More detail for Simple fragrance-free-labelled wash
Before buying
Aligned local panels; priced by mass, with a newly checked 500 g alternative shown separately. [125][115, 71, 116, 84, 125]
Oat-based fragrance-free-labelled wash
Aveeno Skin Relief
RM127.92 · 1 L
The local list includes SLES and Quaternium-15; check the supplied panel if avoiding either ingredient. [22, 59, 86]
More detail for Oat-based fragrance-free-labelled wash
Before buying
The local list includes SLES and Quaternium-15; check the supplied panel if avoiding either ingredient. [22, 59, 86]
Fragrance-free-labelled body wash
Ceradan Moisturising Wash
RM85.00 · 500 ml
Its lipid-ratio claim does not prove it beats other body washes. [25, 61, 84, 152]
More detail for Fragrance-free-labelled body wash
Before buying
Its lipid-ratio claim does not prove it beats other body washes. [25, 61, 84, 152]
Fragrance-free oil format
None ranked
—
No confirmed fragrance-free-labelled shower oil is ranked; fragrance-free washes remain above. [151, 149]
More detail for Fragrance-free oil format
Before buying
No confirmed fragrance-free-labelled shower oil is ranked; fragrance-free washes remain above. [151, 149]
Yukazan fig or floral ritual
Yukazan 75 Fresh Fig / 55 Bluebell
RM69.90 · 500 ml
Choose floral Bluebell or airy Fig; MY percentages are unverified and the Watsons 75 listing differs. [154, 153, 4]
More detail for Yukazan fig or floral ritual
Before buying
Choose floral Bluebell or airy Fig; MY percentages are unverified and the Watsons 75 listing differs. [154, 153, 4]
Yuzu/green-tea scent ritual
Vase Midnight Shikoku
RM58.00 · 330 ml
Contains parfum; the small RM22 bottle lowers trial spending without improving unit cost. [18, 73, 80, 83]
More detail for Yuzu/green-tea scent ritual
Before buying
Contains parfum; the small RM22 bottle lowers trial spending without improving unit cost. [18, 73, 80, 83]
Fragranced comfort option via import
Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil
RM105.75 · 1 L
Contains parfum and ships from France; add delivery costs before comparing it with local offers. [9, 10, 54, 60]
More detail for Fragranced comfort option via import
Before buying
Contains parfum and ships from France; add delivery costs before comparing it with local offers. [9, 10, 54, 60]
Luxury tuberose ritual
Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil
RM275.00 · 200 ml
An exact KENS retail oil, with no proved hydration premium or identified hotel-amenity match. [117, 64, 84]
More detail for Luxury tuberose ritual
Before buying
An exact KENS retail oil, with no proved hydration premium or identified hotel-amenity match. [117, 64, 84]
Buying notes & calculation details
Use the overall score for the stated low-fragrance everyday default, then choose by need below. Fragrance enthusiasts and strict fragrance-avoidance shoppers have different priorities; a conditional score does not resolve a label conflict. [127, 171, 51, 84]
Before you buy
These label and version questions can change what you buy. [4, 24, 120, 52]
Checks that matter
Product / issue
Before buying
Dove Sensitive Skin
The checked Malaysian 550 ml list contains perfume. [20]
More detail for Dove Sensitive Skin
Essential check
The checked Malaysian 550 ml list contains perfume. [20]
Dove Deeply Nourishing
Watsons titles 550 ml; a separate retailer photo says Beauty Nourishing 500 ml, so verify the supplied bottle. [121]
More detail for Dove Deeply Nourishing
Essential check
Watsons titles 550 ml; a separate retailer photo says Beauty Nourishing 500 ml, so verify the supplied bottle. [121]
Aveeno Skin Relief
The local Watsons ingredient list includes Quaternium-15; check the supplied label if avoiding this ingredient. [86]
More detail for Aveeno Skin Relief
Essential check
The local Watsons ingredient list includes Quaternium-15; check the supplied label if avoiding this ingredient. [86]
Cetaphil Ultra Gentle
The brand’s fragrance-free label conflicts with a retailer panel listing heliotropine, a sourced fragrance material; verify the bottle. [120]
More detail for Cetaphil Ultra Gentle
Essential check
The brand’s fragrance-free label conflicts with a retailer panel listing heliotropine, a sourced fragrance material; verify the bottle. [120]
Yagishi with Ceramide
The reference label says both fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented; resolve it before strict fragrance avoidance. [24]
More detail for Yagishi with Ceramide
Essential check
The reference label says both fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented; resolve it before strict fragrance avoidance. [24]
Eucerin pH5 oil
Fragranced and unperfumed versions exist, but the full ingredient panel of the quoted MY offer is unverified. [52, 53, 67]
More detail for Eucerin pH5 oil
Essential check
Fragranced and unperfumed versions exist, but the full ingredient panel of the quoted MY offer is unverified. [52, 53, 67]
Naturium Glow Getter
Its coconut/vanilla presentation and no-artificial-fragrance claim do not establish scentlessness. [32, 55, 70]
More detail for Naturium Glow Getter
Essential check
Its coconut/vanilla presentation and no-artificial-fragrance claim do not establish scentlessness. [32, 55, 70]
Imports and reference photos
Imported merchandise quotes exclude unverified delivery costs; photos show reference packaging, not the supplied batch. [54, 60, 116]
More detail for Imports and reference photos
Essential check
Imported merchandise quotes exclude unverified delivery costs; photos show reference packaging, not the supplied batch. [54, 60, 116]
Buying notes & calculation details
Read the exact regional bottle label, particularly if fragrance avoidance is essential. Manufacturer and retailer pages can disagree; an oil name is not a formulation standard. [4, 24, 120, 52, 84]
Which Yukazan shower oil to choose
Choose the scent you like; an Indonesian 95% olive-oil claim does not verify the Malaysian bottle or a hydration hierarchy. [154, 153]
Official Yukazan variants
Official variant
Advertised scent
Bottle
Price
RM / 100 ml
Before buying
55% Purification
Floral · bluebell
500 ml
RM69.90
RM13.98
Water-led published list; includes olive oil, shea butter, SLES and ceramide. [1, 76, 116] Each official 100 ml trial bottle is RM28.90. [80]
More detail for 55% Purification
Formula / buying distinction
Water-led published list; includes olive oil, shea butter, SLES and ceramide. [1, 76, 116]
75% Hydrating
Airy · fig
500 ml
RM69.90
RM13.98
Butter/oil-led published list; includes SLES and ceramide; Watsons listing differs. [2, 4, 77, 116] Each official 100 ml trial bottle is RM28.90. [80]
More detail for 75% Hydrating
Formula / buying distinction
Butter/oil-led published list; includes SLES and ceramide; Watsons listing differs. [2, 4, 77, 116]
95% Rejuvenation
Warm · woody
300 ml
RM69.90
RM23.30
Different surfactant system; no ceramide listed; unit cost is 66.7% higher than 55/75. [3, 78, 79] Each official 100 ml trial bottle is RM28.90. [80]
More detail for 95% Rejuvenation
Formula / buying distinction
Different surfactant system; no ceramide listed; unit cost is 66.7% higher than 55/75. [3, 78, 79]
Buying notes & calculation details
Choose floral Bluebell, airy Fresh Fig or warm woody Calm Ebony. An Indonesian flagship listing claims 95% olive oil for its Nourishing product, but that does not verify the percentage in the Malaysian Rejuvenation bottle or prove a hydration hierarchy. [154, 153]
The Malaysian page gives no quantitative definition and publishes a shea-first ingredient list; the Indonesian listing also advertises Meadowfoam, which the MY list does not name. Regional equivalence and the percentage basis remain unverified. The higher-numbered MY bottle costs more per volume without a demonstrated offsetting advantage. [153, 79]
The official 100 ml bottles each cost RM28.90 and reduce the amount spent trying a scent. Watsons’ similarly named 75% 500 ml listing is a separate unresolved formula/scent identity at RM69 reference, with a RM62.10 member-labelled offer; it is not treated as a cheaper bottle of official Fresh Fig. [56, 80]
Choose a scent style
Spa / aromatic groups Vase and both Plant Origins washes; citrus/tea and herbal/wood directions still differ. Plant leads at the current Member quote; scores rate formulation and price, while Vase is the known scent fit for a shopper who already enjoys it. [159, 174, 168]
Within Spa / aromatic
Group rank
Product
Refer /100
Scent direction
Before buying
=1
Plant Origins Citrus Breeze
78.1
Citrus · zesty
RM39.90 Member/500 ml; the closest advertised citrus alternative to try, with eligibility and checkout price to verify. [161, 168, 174]
More detail for =1
Price basis
RM39.90 Member · 500 ml
How to choose
Closest advertised citrus alternative to try; verify membership eligibility and checkout price. [161, 168, 174]
=1
Plant Origins Wild Wood
78.1
Herbal · woody
RM39.90 Member/500 ml; the herbal/wood branch ties Citrus Breeze, with eligibility and checkout price to verify. [162, 168, 174]
More detail for =1
Price basis
RM39.90 Member · 500 ml
How to choose
The herbal/wood branch; equal formulation/price score, with a different scent. [162, 170, 174]
3
Vase Midnight Shikoku
73.7
Citrus · tea
RM58/330 ml; yuzu/green tea is an established fit for a shopper who already enjoys Vase. [73, 174]
More detail for 3
Price basis
RM58 · 330 ml
How to choose
Yuzu/green tea; an established fit for a shopper who already enjoys it. [18, 73, 174]
Other scent styles
Product
Scent style
Scent notes
Before buying
Yukazan 55 Bluebell
Floral
Bluebell
Bluebell is floral; no established citrus/tea match. [154, 160]
More detail for Yukazan 55 Bluebell
How it relates
A floral branch rather than an established citrus/tea match. [154, 160]
Yukazan 75 Fresh Fig
Fresh / fruity
Airy · fig
Fresh Fig is an airy adjacent option, with no advertised yuzu/tea match. [154, 160]
More detail for Yukazan 75 Fresh Fig
How it relates
A fresh adjacent option; no advertised yuzu/tea match. [154, 160]
Yukazan 95 Calm Ebony
Woody
Warm · woody
Calm Ebony is warm woody; no confirmed citrus/herbal note match. [154, 160]
More detail for Yukazan 95 Calm Ebony
How it relates
An adjacent warm-wood option; no confirmed citrus/herbal note match. [154, 160]
L’Occitane Almond
Sweet / gourmand
Almond · vanilla
Almond/vanilla is the food-inspired gourmand direction. [114, 160]
More detail for L’Occitane Almond
How it relates
The food-inspired almond/vanilla direction. [114, 160]
Naturium Glow Getter
Sweet / gourmand
Coconut · vanilla
Coconut/vanilla is another food-inspired direction. [32, 160]
More detail for Naturium Glow Getter
How it relates
Another food-inspired direction, with different advertised notes. [32, 160]
Spa / aromatic is a shared shopping style for Vase and both Plant Origins washes. Yuzu/green tea and lemon/orange/grapefruit belong to its fresh citrus branch; lavender/clary sage/cedarwood belong to its herbal/wood branch. These directions do not establish identical smells or a formal perfume-family standard. [159, 161, 162]
Use style to narrow the field, then compare formulation, price and specific notes. Plant Origins leads this trio at its current labelled member offer; scores do not rate smell. Vase is the known scent fit for a shopper who already enjoys it, while Citrus Breeze is the closest advertised citrus direction to try. [174, 168]
Plant's listed member offer gives RM7.98/100 ml, versus Vase's RM17.58/100 ml. Its lower merchandise cost outweighs the authored conditioning difference; this does not prove better hydration or a preferred smell. The RM90 RRP is only a hypothetical reference scenario. Scent strength, persistence and post-wash feel were not tested. [168, 173, 174, 116]
Styles condense advertised descriptions, not Refer smell tests. No added scent follows fragrance-free labels without promising odourlessness; Unknown means insufficient notes, and Unverified preserves a scent/version question. The separate scent-label field and bottle qualifications remain. Personal liking is a preference facet and does not change the general-use merit scores. [160, 155, 167]
Full research & product notes
The complete inventory, alternatives and limits behind the recommendations.
The ranking
The ranking
The four named cleansing/foaming oil products are excluded by the requested scope; this is not a composition or performance judgement. No confirmed fragrance-free-labelled shower oil remains in this field. [149, 151]
Scores are provisional Refer AI editorial assessments out of 100; order is derived and equal totals share positions. Nearby scores are weak distinctions. Existing merchandise quotes were checked on 4 October 2026; Plant Origins uses its separately labelled 10 October Member offer; compare shipping, exact size and discount conditions before checkout. *QV is sold by mass and displays RM/100 g; its affordability points use an explicitly approximate manufacturer density proxy. Unverified owner country and release/age mean the necessary evidence was not established, rather than a performance penalty. [127, 108, 125, 171, 126, 50, 116, 168, 173]
Prices, smaller bottles and refills
Prices, smaller bottles and refills
The volume table below sorts affordability of exact quoted configurations, not product merit. Stock changes neither a calculation nor a performance assessment. Prices are checked merchandise offers before unverified delivery costs; the quoted reference/discount price is retained for sensitivity. [127, 116]
QV’s quoted 1.25 kg pack costs RM91.12, or RM7.29/100 g. Exact delivered-bottle volume is unmeasured, so the exact-volume price ordering contains millilitre-labelled offers only; scoring uses the separately disclosed approximate manufacturer density. Caring’s 500 g alternative is now priced and assessed separately. Refills and minis change spending and unit cost, not the evidence of cleansing performance. [115, 71, 116, 125]
Configuration
Merchandise price
RM / 100 ml
Use
Yukazan 55 / 75 / 95 mini · 100 ml
RM28.90
RM28.90
Lower trial spending; each exact scent remains separate. [80, 83]
Lower bottle spending; 1 L has lower unit cost at the checked offer. [80, 83]
L’Occitane Almond · 250 ml
RM125.00
RM50.00
Lower bottle spending than the 500 ml configuration. [80, 83]
L’Occitane Almond refill · 500 ml
RM200.00
RM40.00
For an appropriate refillable container; bottle is RM45/100 ml. [80, 83]
Bioderma Atoderm refill · 1 L
RM100.69
RM10.07
French import; pump is RM10.58/100 ml before delivery. [54, 83]
Plant Origins totals use the actual current RM39.90 offer with Member visibly retained as a price condition. Ordinary non-member checkout price remains unverified; the crossed-out RM90 RRP is only a hypothetical reference scenario. [167, 168, 173]
What the outcome evidence actually shows
What the outcome evidence actually shows
The historical summaries include excluded cleansing oils for evidence continuity; those products receive no position in the current ranking. [149]
All rows below describe brand-published summaries, not a full independent comparative trial inspected by this researcher. “Dermatological control” does not itself establish randomization, blinding or a comparator.
Product
Sample
Method/duration
Reported outcome (attributed)
Comparator
Key uncertainty
Evidence
Bioderma
52; age 20–70; dry skin
27 days; corneometry; 24-hour claim tied to use period
+26%; up to 39% wording
UNKNOWN
Formula code of tested batch, comparator, blinding, protocol/full data; brand-published
UNKNOWN for a relevant inspected finished-product comparison
No comparable full protocol recovered
Claims/ingredients/positioning do not substitute for outcomes
UNKNOWN
No cross-product clinical score assigned
Product-specific ledger
Sponsorship: the summaries are published on manufacturer pages; formal funding/conflict-of-interest statements and the full underlying reports were not recovered. They should not be described as independent validation. Test populations are not automatically representative of every shopper. No ingredient-level mechanism is converted into a demonstrated clinical benefit for a finished rinse-off formula.
Eucerin’s Malaysian page adds a brand-published two-week consumer-use study of 119 women, reporting 99% gentle cleansing, 98% protection from drying and 97% softer/smoother feeling. It is not a recovered independent head-to-head trial; the C8+ generation is also not the old Uriage study formula. These different endpoints and test designs cannot establish a numerical winner. [52, 118, 84]
Ingredient panels and exact regional boundaries
Ingredient panels and exact regional boundaries
Previously researched cleansing and foaming oil panels are retained as historical evidence, outside the current ranked field. [149]
These are transcriptions of the retrieved page lists, not laboratory analyses. Source spelling, nonstandard parenthetical wording and damaged text are preserved where material. The lists are associated only with the indicated page/region/selection. A matching name, size or fragrance-free claim is not enough to establish a matching batch. Exact percentages or pH are not inferred from ingredient order.
Yukazan 55% Purification — official Bluebell, both checked sizes
Qualification: The source spelling 'Melasma Candidum' is preserved, not corrected. Bluebell scent is advertised although no Parfum entry is shown; absence of that word is not proof of fragrance-free.
Yukazan 75% Hydrating — official Fresh Fig, both checked sizes
Aqua, Sodium Lau eth Sulfate, Glyce i , Cocamidop opyl Betai e, Cap ylyl/Cap y Glucoside, Peg-40 Hyd oge ated Casto Oil, Peg-150 Distea ate, Phe oxyetha ol, Sodium Chlo ide, Hyd oxyp opyl Methylcellulose, Be zoic Acid, So bic Acid, Ce amide Np, Butyrospe mum Pa kii (Shea) Butte , Hippophae Rham oides F uit Oil, Butyle e Glycol, Vacci ium A gustifoli Um (Bluebe y) F uit Ext act, Cit us G a dis (G apef uit) F uit Ext act, Ci19140, Ci15985
Qualification: Missing letters are in the retrieved source text. This is not silently normalized into an authoritative package INCI. Even allowing for damaged text, the sequence differs materially from the official Fresh Fig page.
Qualification: The parenthetical Bluebell wording conflicts with the oud-wood product description. Do not correct the botanical or fragrance identity by guesswork.
Qualification: Retailer spelling 'polyquarternium' retained. The brand fragrance-free claim conflicts with listed heliotropine, identified by primary references as a fragrance material; its specific product purpose, dose and supplied-bottle identity remain unverified. [120]
Qualification: Preserved as the page's text, not accepted as an established wash formula. An emulsion/lotion-panel misattribution is a hypothesis requiring supplier confirmation.
Material ingredient panels not recovered
Product
What is missing
Treatment
Current Malaysian L'Occitane A26 bottles/refill
Delivered-bottle formula match
Current same-code Saudi reference recovered; Malaysian batch not certified by it. [109]
Yagishi ceramide and fragrance versions
Full current INCI
Highlighted ingredients and label photographs are not treated as a complete formula.
diptyque Revitalizing / Do Son
Exact supplied-bottle INCI
Current US Do Son reference recovered; not transferred to Revitalizing or treated as a verified Malaysian batch. [110]
KUNDAL non-default scent variants
Variant-specific perfume/allergen panel
Default Ylang Ylang list not copied across all scents.
Preference evidence only, not product-level clinical evidence.
Malaysian import batches of Bioderma, LRP, Avène, CeraVe and Naturium
Physical or seller-supplied current batch label match
Regional reference composition retained with explicit applicability limits.
QV Gentle Wash — Malaysian 1.25 kg
Official and retailer panels: Aqua (Water), Glycerin, Sodium Lauroyl Sarcosinate, Disodium Cocoamphodiacetate, Lauryl Betaine, Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate, Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer, Styrene/Acrylates Copolymer, Aminomethyl Propanol, Methylparaben, Propylparaben. This is a page transcription, not an assay of the delivered batch. [115]
Current references recovered during scoring
A current same-code L’Occitane Saudi reference, a US Do Son DOSSHOILV2 reference and a French Uriage C8+ formula 44455-29 now support conditional design assessments. They do not prove Malaysian delivered-bottle matches. Old Uriage study/launch evidence stays separate. Eucerin’s offered fragrance version and full INCI remain unknown. [109, 110, 111, 52, 53]
QV’s manufacturer SDS states approximate density; exact label pricing remains per 100 g. Yagishi’s manufacturer design claims are retained with low confidence and an unresolved complete formula. [108, 125, 112]
Plant Origins Citrus Breeze Body Wash — current primary 500 ml reference
Qualification: Brand-published panel, not a physical supplied-bottle inspection; essential oils are scent materials, and no comparable outcome trial was established. [161, 163]
Plant Origins Wild Wood Body Wash — current primary 500 ml reference
Qualification: Brand-published panel, not a physical supplied-bottle inspection; essential oils are scent materials, and no comparable outcome trial was established. [162, 163]
Ownership, manufacture and release age
Ownership, manufacture and release age
The historical ownership and date observations below also retain excluded cleansers; they are not recommendations or current ranks. [149]
Owner country means majority control, not the brand’s origin, head office or place of manufacture. Avène’s French foundation-controlled group and QV’s explicit Australian-owned family-company declaration are supported. Other checked parent/operator pages do not establish a current majority-country answer; those entries stay Unverified. This buying fact never changes merit; Plant Origins’ Malaysian manufacture claim does not establish majority-country ownership. [126, 43, 163]
The current-formula earliest global sale date and derived age are unknown for the offered products, including the added Plant Origins washes. CeraVe’s dated US name-existence observation gives a minimum age for the named product only; it does not date the imported formulation. Launch dates remain useful buying facts; recency merit is exempt because age is not monotonic in this category, independently of the missing cycle evidence. [50, 82, 127]
Historical named product
On sale / existed by
Age bound to 4 Oct 2026
Boundary
US Lipikar Gentle Foaming oil
27 Jul 2023
≥1,165 days / ≥3y 2m
Purchased review; does not date the international oil. [15, 82]
US CeraVe foaming oil
27 Jul 2023
≥1,165 days / ≥3y 2m
Name-existence only; not current import formula. [15, 82]
Retained customer-review bound; not C8+. [36, 118]
What we did not rank, and why
What we did not rank, and why
The main field receives provisional formulation-and-price ranks under the stated everyday-use default; both Plant Origins body washes have now joined it under explicit RRP assumptions. The additional candidates below are retained with their precise evidence or scope limits. A missing price, blocked page or incomplete formula check does not establish inferiority or absence from Malaysia. [127, 85]
Additional candidate
Treatment / reason
Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil
Excluded cleansing/foaming oil format; earlier evidence retained without a current rank. [149]
Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil
Excluded cleansing/foaming oil format; earlier evidence retained without a current rank. [149]
CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser
Excluded cleansing/foaming oil format; earlier evidence retained without a current rank. [149]
La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international
Excluded cleansing/foaming oil format; earlier evidence retained without a current rank. [149]
KUNDAL Pure — Ylang Ylang, White Musk, Baby Powder, Cherry Blossom, Pink Grapefruit, English Rose, Amber Woody
Foreign scent identities and formula are retained; current exact Malaysian seller offers and batch equivalence unresolved. Old Ceradan-like ingredient sequence is not KUNDAL evidence. [28, 29, 26]
Yukazan Relax Zen / Just Charm
Separate essential-oil washes, each RM44.90/500 ml; conflicting scent/ingredient-parenthesis descriptions require confirmation. [6, 7, 81]
Yukazan Firming Fit
Ordinary wash profile retained at RM44.90/300 ml; no fat-loss or firming endorsement. [8, 81]
Yukazan Watsons 75 listing
Separate unresolved scent/formula identity; RM69 reference and RM62.10 member offer retained outside the official Fresh Fig row. [4, 56]
Yukazan 30 ml gifts / past limited editions
Not-for-sale samples and unverified limited-edition leads do not establish a current ordinary offer. [5, 81]
Diptyque Revitalizing / Oyedo
Revitalizing is a separate fragranced hair/body gel, RM249/200 ml at a sold-out import listing; Oyedo’s current MY offer unverified. No Do Son or hotel identity merge. [30, 31, 48, 85]
US Lipikar Gentle Foaming oil
Separate fragrance-free US formula; no exact current MY offer verified. Its cleanser-plus-cream result is not oil alone. [12, 14, 16]
Old Uriage Xémose regional oil
Formula and old study retained separately; no transfer to C8+. [35, 36, 118]
elemental herbology — Mercure 480 ml / Neroli & Bergamot 370 ml
Exact hotel/retail equivalence and formula remain unresolved; the 370 ml Malaysian listing was sold out with a voucher-only price. [38, 39, 49]
Outside eligible scope or insufficiently identified; no guessed identity or borrowed ingredients. [127, 85]
The earlier complete field’s base and scenario positions are explicitly historical. [150] The excluded products’ earlier assessments and source records remain historical evidence, without a current rank. [118, 72, 126, 50, 100, 116, 84, 111, 133, 127, 171, 119, 122, 33, 34, 43, 58, 87, 135, 37, 15, 42, 62, 82, 91, 136, 13, 16, 69, 97, 138]
The previous scored field and Plant scent-reference-only treatment remain explicitly historical; current positions and the completed Plant assessments replace those earlier dispositions. The older fresh-aromatic interpretation is also retained as a narrower description within the new Spa / aromatic shopping group. [166, 156, 171, 172, 165]
Method and confidence
Method and confidence
These scores are Refer’s provisional AI editorial assessments of documented formulation design and dated merchandise affordability. They are not observed tolerability, hydration, cleansing effectiveness or predicted scent liking. No hands-on trial or common clinical benchmark was performed; old external bars and third-party percentages are not our scores. [127, 84, 119]
Criterion
Weight
What the judgement means
Daily low-fragrance fit
40%
Fit of documented daily-cleansing design for a low-fragrance default; individual tolerance unknown. [127, 113]
Conditioning formulation
33⅓%
Humectant/emollient design intent; no assumed skin deposition or clinical magnitude. [127, 84]
Merchandise affordability
26⅔%
Continuous log preference on exact dated listed unit cost; no shipping, voucher or channel penalty. [127, 116, 125]
The weights retain the original cleansing:comfort:value proportions. Clinical outcomes were replaced by explicit design judgements, practical rinse/residue points were removed without a common discriminating benchmark, and recency is exempt because newer cleanser recipes are not inherently better. Release/age remain shown as facts or Unverified; bottle shelf life is a different question. The original rubric and research remain preserved. [127, 50, 84]
Qualitative points are deliberately coarse judgements; the decimal total is only weighted arithmetic. Each total covers every criterion and is computed by Refer’s ScoringService. Exact unrounded ties share positions; alphabetical ordering within a tie has no merit meaning. Equal displayed one-decimal scores can have different positions when their unrounded totals differ; the ordering does not establish a meaningful clinical gap. Confidence describes applicability and never adds points or breaks a tie. Stock, imports, seller access and owner country are buying facts only. [127, 171, 119]
The formulation scores assume the stated regional reference or accurately described manufacturer design applies. Cetaphil follows the retailer’s scent-material panel and receives no fragrance-free fit bonus; Eucerin’s baseline uses the lightly fragranced design because the offered version is unknown. Imported reference formulas and Yagishi’s claim-based assessments remain low confidence. Nearby estimates are not established clinical differences. Several leading washes have similar design assessments; their dated price basis determines their close overall ordering. The affordability preference can outweigh a formulation trade-off. Ordinary documented scented designs receive 75 and aligned low-fragrance references 90, a 6.0-point weighted preference; 50 requires a separately documented functional mismatch beyond fragrance. Strict fragrance avoidance is a buying requirement to apply through the labels and bottle checks. [127][171, 172][120, 52, 112, 171]
Prices and stock are page observations on 4 October 2026, not completed orders. Ordinary displayed offers are the base; retailer reference prices and refill scenarios are shown separately. QV’s approximate density proxy is disclosed and stress-tested, while its table retains RM/100 g. Delivery, dose per shower, delivered batches and personal reactions remain unverified. [116, 80, 108, 125]
Scores and derivations
Scores and derivations
The two design scores are provisional Refer author judgements; value and totals are arithmetic under the declared preference. The full reasons are in each cited evidence record; a low score is not a safety verdict. [127, 171, 119, 169, 170]
Product
Cleansing design
Conditioning design
Affordability
Refer /100
Confidence / assumption
QV Gentle Wash
90.0
80.0
89.1
86.4
Medium; Base price uses 1.25 kg; the checked 500 g alternative and its reference-price sensitivity are shown separately. [125, 71][128]
Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash
90.0
80.0
72.9
82.1
Medium; Local formula differs from US; check Quaternium-15 if avoiding it. [22, 86][129]
Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash
75.0
75.0
100.0
81.7
Low; Watsons 550 ml title/list assessed conditionally; another retailer’s 500 ml Beauty Nourishing photo does not confirm the bottle. [121, 65][130]
Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash
75.0
75.0
100.0
81.7
Medium; The checked Malaysian formula is perfumed. [20][131]
Ceradan Moisturising Wash
90.0
85.0
64.7
81.6
Medium; Lipid-ratio marketing is not a comparative clinical result. [25, 26][132]
Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil
75.0
85.0
78.4
79.2
Low; Perfumed France import; add actual shipping at checkout. [54, 60][134]
Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash
75
80.0
81.2
78.3
Low; Fragrance-free label conflicts with retailer heliotropine panel; no fragrance-free scoring bonus. [120][137]
Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell
75.0
80.0
70.3
75.4
Medium; Bluebell scent; percentage meaning unverified. [1, 57][139]
Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig
75.0
80.0
70.3
75.4
Medium; Official Fresh Fig; Watsons similarly named listing differs. [4, 77][140]
Medium; Same provisional design tier; its smaller bottle increases unit cost. [78, 79][144]
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide
75.0
75.0
58.9
70.7
Low; Claim-based design score; full INCI and fragrance-label conflict unresolved. [24, 112][145]
L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil
75.0
85.0
36.6
68.1
Low; Almond/vanilla ritual premium; Malaysian formula match unverified. [109, 68][146]
Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash
75.0
85.0
35.5
67.8
Low; Scented reference; high exact marketplace merchandise cost. [32, 70][147]
Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil
75.0
85.0
4.4
59.5
Low; Luxury perfume ritual price; not a demonstrated hydration premium. [110, 64][148]
Plant Origins Citrus Breeze Body Wash
75.0
75.0
86.5
78.1
Low; current RM39.90 Member quote is conditional; supplied bottle not inspected. [169, 168]
Plant Origins Wild Wood Body Wash
75.0
75.0
86.5
78.1
Low; current RM39.90 Member quote is conditional; supplied bottle not inspected. [170, 168]
Value = clamp(0,100,100 − 20 × log₂(p/5)), where p is the unrounded dated MYR merchandise cost per 100 ml; QV uses its approximate density proxy. The anchors are RM5=100, RM10=80, RM20=60, RM40=40, RM80=20 and RM160=0. A price doubling costs twenty affordability points between the bounds; small price changes no longer cross a score cliff. This does not estimate consumption per shower. [127, 125]
QV uses 90 × 0.40 + 80 × 0.333333 + 89.1 × 0.266667 ≈ 86.4; the stored calculation uses unrounded value. Yukazan 55/75 share 75.4; 95’s 71.5 differs only through its higher unit cost. [125, 124]
What changes the order
What changes the order
These are preference and price scenarios, not observed performance. Design ±5 moves both qualitative estimates together; the scent-indifferent scenario gives every cleansing design the same 90. Retailer reference prices replace recorded offers where available; “same basis” means no reference price was recorded. Smaller bottles/refills have their own dated costs and are not silently substituted. [123, 122]
Cetaphil would reach 84.3 only if a matched bottle/manufacturer correction resolved the fragrance-material conflict; its current baseline is 78.3. Eucerin would reach 78.7 if the offered formula were confirmed unperfumed. These are conditional scenarios, not verified second scores. [120, 123]
QV’s deliberately broad 0.8–1.2 g/ml density assumptions give approximate totals 88.1–85.0; these are neither manufacturer tolerances nor statistical intervals. Its large quoted pack contributes to the value result; the checked 500 g Caring sale pack gives 84.2 and its reference price gives 81.0 under the same approximate-density method. A scent or luxury preference can reasonably change the purchase. [125, 127]
Pack and price-preference sensitivity
Pack and price-preference sensitivity
QV’s smaller 500 g Caring pack is RM48.90 (RM9.78/100 g), with a RM74.03 reference price (RM14.806/100 g), checked 5 October 2026. Under the same approximate density, its conditional totals are 84.2 at the offer and 81.0 at reference. The bulk pack remains the main ranking’s exact price basis; these are separate configurations. Other sizes and checkout costs remain unverified. [125]
The following changes only the editorial price slope from twenty to ten affordability points per doubling, keeping every base weight and design assessment. It is a preference scenario, not an observed result or the published order. Scenario positions use the expanded current field; Plant Origins retains the conditional Member offer basis. [172, 171, 168]
Matched independent body-cleansing trials, verified regional recipes and changed prices could change these provisional assessments. Exact packaging checks could resolve the Cetaphil and Yagishi fragrance conflict, Eucerin’s fragrance version, imported regional recipes and the Watsons Yukazan identity. A reproducible percentage definition could clarify Yukazan’s names without automatically proving a clinical advantage. [120, 24, 52, 4, 57, 84]
Recheck the exact offers and discount conditions before buying, and refresh local availability before its recorded check becomes stale. A confirmed ordinary Malaysian offer for KUNDAL or an identified hotel amenity could broaden the choices. Current-formula launch evidence would improve the displayed age facts; it would not automatically improve merit points under this category exemption. [50, 116, 85]
Plant Origins price basis and spa-choice sensitivity
Plant Origins price basis and spa-choice sensitivity
Version 2.3 adopts actual dated offers with their conditions visible. Both Plant Origins totals are 78.1 at the current RM39.90 Member quote and tie within Spa / aromatic, above Vase 73.7. Eligibility and current checkout terms remain buying checks; membership and stock earn no points. At the hypothetical RM90 RRP reference, both totals would be 71.8, reversing that group order; RRP is not a verified ordinary purchase quote. [167, 168, 171, 173, 174]
The independent challenge rejected the first RRP-based preparation. Its exact claims, arithmetic and raw verdict remain historical; the price basis is now repaired. The reviewer’s rank-6 assertion for Plant 78.1 was incorrect: Bioderma 79.2 and Cetaphil 78.3 still precede both Plant entries, which share overall rank =8. [175, 171]
For a shopper already satisfied with Vase’s scent, continuing with Vase preserves an established individual fit. Citrus Breeze is the closest advertised citrus direction to try; Wild Wood provides the herbal/wood branch. No blind comparison established which aroma that shopper would prefer, how strongly it projects, how long it persists or how the washes feel after rinsing. [174, 159]
The design column now names the applied low-fragrance fit preference directly; every numerical assessment and weight stays unchanged. Both ordinary scented and aligned low-fragrance references are documented body-cleanser designs; their applied tier difference is a preference, not a measured cleansing or irritation result. [177] The fresh Cetaphil check still finds a fragrance-free description and heliotropine on the same exact retailer page, so a two-SKU explanation remains unproved and the supplied bottle needs verification. [176]
Sources & methodology
Check the original context, assessment criteria and dated evidence.
Original research summary
Under the low-fragrance default, QV leads at 86.4; with scent preference removed, Dove leads at 87.7. Aveeno and Ceradan are fragrance-free-labelled alternatives. Fragranced Bioderma is the highest-scoring shower oil at its quoted import price before shipping; Yukazan 55/75 tie at 75.4. Close scores and scent preferences can change the choice. [128, 134, 124, 125, 122, 171, 60, 158]
How this was scored
A sensible everyday rinse-off body cleanser for an adult who values a low-fragrance cleansing formula, conditioning ingredients and Malaysian merchandise cost. The overall order is this general-use editorial default; fragrance enthusiasts should also use the separate scent-led picks. A formulation assessment is an informed judgement about documented design, not a measurement of cleansing, hydration or irritation in an individual.
Daily low-fragrance fit — 40% · Editorial assessment of the documented rinse-off cleansing design for the low-fragrance everyday default. Consider the whole cleansing system, soap-free/pH positioning and intentional fragrance or sensory additives. SLES, preservatives, natural ingredients or an oil name alone neither prove harm nor earn a bonus. This is not observed tolerability.
Conditioning formulation — 33.3% · Editorial assessment of the documented humectant/emollient/lipid design and moisturizing positioning. Assess their role in the whole formula; do not count ingredients, linearly reward percentages, presume skin deposition or translate incomparable brand studies into points. This is not measured post-wash hydration.
Malaysian merchandise affordability — 26.7% · Apply the continuous declared preference to the exact dated bottle’s unrounded MYR/100 ml merchandise cost p: value = clamp(0,100,100 − 20 × log₂(p / 5)). At RM5, RM10, RM20, RM40, RM80 and RM160 per 100 ml, values are 100, 80, 60, 40, 20 and 0. Doubling merchandise unit cost costs 20 affordability points between the bounds; this is an editorial preference, not an efficacy or use-rate measurement. Use the explicitly labelled dated offer and its price conditions; member offers are conditional price inputs, with membership eligibility shown rather than scored. Exclude vouchers, shipping estimates and refills requiring an existing container. QV retains RM/100 g in the table; any volume proxy must have sourced density and remain labelled approximate. Stock and channel never affect this score.
Sources & evidence
The records behind this guide, with the dates and limits of each source.
1
Yukazan 55% Purification / official 55% Purification
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04
YK55 / official 55% Purification — 500ml and 100ml pages describe Bluebell fragrance and an oil-to-milk wash; the two published INCI lists match. '55%' is in the name, without a recoverable quantitative definition. Qualification: Scent/transition are brand descriptions, not our sensory testing. Full label and batch were not physically inspected.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
YK75 / official 75% Hydrating — 500ml and 100ml pages describe Fresh Fig and publish the same shea/olive/seabuckthorn-led ingredient sequence. Qualification: This is not the ingredient sequence or scent published by Watsons for its 75% listing.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation / official 95% Rejuvenation
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04
YK95 / official 95% Rejuvenation — 300ml and 100ml pages describe Calm Ebony and publish the same ingredient sequence beginning shea butter, olive fruit oil and PEG-40 hydrogenated castor oil. Qualification: No ceramide is listed in this 95% INCI. The percentage is not an independently verified total-oil measurement.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
YK75-W / Watsons 75% 500ml — Watsons describes ambrette seed, sea salt and sage, and publishes a water/SLES/glycerin-led INCI different from the official Fresh Fig pages. Qualification: Text has missing letters. Whether this is an older formula, a different SKU, or a publishing error is UNKNOWN; do not merge formula or price.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Yukazan catalogue scope — The checked catalogue exposes the three core shower-oil variants in six size listings and adjacent Relax Zen, Just Charm and Firming Fit washes. No additional limited-edition shower-oil formula was verified. Qualification: Not a claim that no other or past edition exists. A not-for-sale 30ml gift/sample and its placeholder price are not a retail offer.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
YK-ZEN / Relax Zen — 500ml body-wash page describes oud wood, but its ingredient list includes 'Cananga Odorata Flower Oil (Bluebell)'. Qualification: The scent description and parenthetical ingredient wording do not align; leave the wording uncorrected pending a label check.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
YK-CHARM / Just Charm — 500ml page describes bluebell/peach-blossom notes, while its INCI includes 'Trichilia Emetica Seed Oil (Oud Wood)'. Qualification: Possible cross-page copy error. This wash is not the core 55% Bluebell oil merely because the description overlaps.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
YK-FIRM / Firming Fit — 300ml page describes pink pepper/cedarwood and makes firming/body-shaping claims; its ingredient list is reproduced in §5. Qualification: No clinical method supports fat breakdown, oedema reduction or a body-shaping effect here; these claims are not endorsed.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
BD / Bioderma regional formula — Opened Australian and Singapore pages list fragrance/parfum in BI725. The Malaysian range page does not establish the exact shower-oil formulation supplied locally. Qualification: Corrects a blanket fragrance-free statement. It does not prove that every imported Malaysian bottle uses BI725.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
BD / hydration evidence — Australian footnotes describe corneometry in 52 dry-skin volunteers aged 20–70 over 27 days: +26% hydration, with an 'up to 39%' statement. The page links 24-hour hydration to this use period. A separate 21-person, one-week use test reports 80% favourable comfort/softness/hydration responses. Qualification: Comparator, randomization, blinding, tested formula code, protocol and full data UNKNOWN. The Singapore headline foregrounds 39%; it should not replace the Australian summary or imply an average 39% gain.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
BD / mechanism claims — The brand attributes lipid-replenishing and bacterial-adhesion effects to its formula and Skin Barrier Therapy complex. Qualification: No recovered head-to-head clinical evidence establishes 'clinically strongest', infection prevention or superiority over the other cleansers.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
LRP-US / current US oil — Current US INCI contains sodium laureth sulfate and no listed parfum or squalane; the brand calls it fragrance-free. Qualification: Soap-free is not sulfate-free. This US formula must not be merged with the fragranced international product.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
La Roche-Posay international oil / international oil
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04
LRP-INT / international oil — Easypara's 400ml listing, EAN 3337875656764 / FIL C224532/1, includes sodium laureth sulfate and parfum in the published INCI. Qualification: Retailer warns composition may vary. Exact formula shipped through another retailer is not established just by a similar name.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
LRP-US / efficacy claims — The US page cites a 10-week regimen combining once-daily oil with twice-daily Lipikar AP+M cream for its 90% roughness/dryness-appearance result; it also displays gentle/soothing/hydration user-perception percentages. Qualification: Not evidence that the oil alone delivers the regimen result. Sample size and full study methods were not verified; PubMed/publisher access did not expose a usable full report.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
LRP-US and CeraVe / dated review — A purchased-product review dated 27 July 2023 calls both foaming-oil products new. The review's historical LRP INCI also includes SLES. It discusses facial use and says body use was not tried. Qualification: On-sale-by bound for names, not earliest global release or current formulation. Reviewer lather preference is not comparative body-cleansing testing.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
LRP / Malaysian identity — The Malaysian Lipikar range lead does not establish a particular cleansing-oil SKU. A separately opened cross-border Malaysian checkout exists for the 400ml oil. Qualification: Local official distribution of the exact US or international oil remains unverified.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
LO / test claims — The 250ml page reports moisturized-appearance and suppleness improvements (+25% and +22%) in a 33-woman, four-week test, and 85% favourable softness self-assessment. Qualification: Comparator, instrument/method, tested batch, sponsorship declaration and full report UNKNOWN. Not directly comparable with corneometry or an independent head-to-head trial.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
VA / current identity — Midnight Shikoku is listed as a 330ml shower oil, with a 100ml selector, yuzu/green-tea scent, and PENTAVITIN/saccharide-isomerate marketing. Qualification: The published INCI names grapefruit seed oil and parfum; it does not establish a quantified yuzu-essential-oil content. Historical 'PENTAVIN' spelling is corrected.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
VA / origin and claims — The brand says it formulates and manufactures in its own GMP-compliant Malaysian facility, names founder Charlotte T., and publishes operator Vase Creation 002882176-K. Qualification: Not an independent GMP audit or proof of current majority ownership. Hydration/barrier/24-hour marketing lacks recovered finished-product study details.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
DV-S / Malaysian Sensitive Skin — Watsons 550ml BP_72592 lists Indonesia as origin and publishes an INCI containing perfume and SLES. Qualification: The opened retailer SKU, not a foreign fragrance-free Dove variant, is assessed. A different brand-page ingredient lead does not establish the same batch.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Dove Deeply Nourishing / Malaysian Deeply Nourishing
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04
DV-D / Malaysian Deeply Nourishing — Watsons 550ml BP_72593 lists Indonesia as origin and an INCI containing perfume and SLES, with a different ordering from Sensitive Skin. Qualification: Separate product from Sensitive Skin. No head-to-head data establishes that one is gentler or more moisturizing.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
AV / Malaysian Skin Relief — Watsons 354ml and 1000ml listings publish the same oat-containing, SLES-containing INCI and fragrance-free positioning; the retailer names Korea as origin. Qualification: Do not substitute a US sulfate-free/triple-oat formula. No recovered clinical trial establishes the old finished-wash 'barrier repair' claim.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Yagishi Ceramide / Yagishi Fragrance / current identity
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04
YG-C / YG-F / current identity — Official pages distinguish Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide from with Fragrance. Official bottle images identify 500ml for both. Qualification: Whether these are formula-identical to the historical 'Premium Goat Milk' wash is UNKNOWN. Complete current INCI was not recovered.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
YG-C / conflicting fragrance labels — The official brown ceramide bottle image simultaneously uses 'Fragrance-Free', '100% Essential Oil Scented' and a geranium-essential-oil hydration statement. Qualification: This is a real label conflict, not proof of an unscented product. Whether 'fragrance-free' means no synthetic fragrance is not established.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
CE / current wash — Watsons publishes a ceramide/cholesterol/fatty-acid wash INCI, fragrance-free/soap-free positioning and a 3:1:1 lipid-ratio claim. Qualification: Contains sodium trideceth sulphate; SLS/SLES-free is not an all-sulfates-free claim. Lipid ratio is not a measured clinical superiority result.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Historical KUNDAL attribution audit — The historical pack's 15-item KUNDAL ingredient sequence matches the sequence now published for Ceradan Moisturising Wash, apart from transcription/spelling differences. Qualification: Strong evidence of misattribution in the old pack, not proof of how the original listicle error occurred. Discard it as KUNDAL evidence.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
CT / channel limitations — The Watsons page returned no usable text and Guardian was blocked; AA Pharmacy and HTM exact-product pages were accessible. Qualification: A blocked/blank page is not evidence of lack of stock or non-distribution.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
KU / actual Pure wash — The current US official Pure page has seven selectable scents: Ylang Ylang, White Musk, Pink Grapefruit, Cherry Blossom, Baby Powder, Amber Vanilla and Amber Woody. The default ingredient panel starts aloe juice and water, unlike the historical Ceradan-like list. Qualification: 500ml / 16.9 fl oz product family. Default Ylang Ylang ingredient panel cannot certify every scent's perfume/allergen blend or any Malaysian batch.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
KU / composition claims — The brand states 42% aloe and pH 5.5, with extract-count marketing that differs from the old pack and foreign listings. Qualification: No independent concentration/pH measurement or comparative performance study recovered. 'Cotton' was not in the checked selector; no exact Malaysian scent offer was verified.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
DP-R / exact retail identity — Strawberrynet's Malaysian page identifies Revitalizing Shower Gel for Body and Hair 200ml, with mandarin/bergamot/neroli-oriented scent copy, and explicitly marks it out of stock. Qualification: A priced cross-border retail product; complete current INCI and exact hotel correspondence remain UNKNOWN. Almond extract in historical sources does not establish almond scent or a user allergy.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
DP-R / historical existence — A dated 8 August 2016 review discusses the retail Revitalizing Shower Gel, 6.8 fl oz, at a stated US price. Qualification: Bounds existence of the named product, not the first global sale or current formula's age.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
NA / corrected identity — The official product is The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash. The page describes 50% glycerin, pH 4.25–4.75 and a coconut/vanilla-oriented scent from its listed fragrance-associated ingredients/extracts. Qualification: Glycerin claim is not oil concentration. A duplicated lower-page pH rendering is inconsistent; no independent pH assay. It is not necessarily scentless because a retailer calls it fragrance-free.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
AX / formula and use — The official UK XeraCalm A.D 400ml page, EAN 3282770389883, states fragrance-free face/body/scalp use and gives the INCI reproduced below. Qualification: UK reference formula, not automatically the exact Malaysian retailer batch. 'Physiological pH' is not a verified numerical pH.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
AX / hydration evidence — Brand footnotes describe 24-hour hydration kinetics after a single application in 22 subjects with dehydrated skin. Qualification: Comparator, randomization, exact tested batch and full study report UNKNOWN. Not a direct comparative effectiveness trial against the other candidates.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
UX / exact oil — The official regional Xémose Cleansing Soothing Oil page gives 200ml, 400ml and 1L options, fragrance-free positioning and body/face use; it publishes an SLES-containing INCI. Qualification: Do not merge with Uriage Cleansing Oil with 25% glycerin, other fragranced oils, or newer C8+ leads without matching the formula.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
UX / comfort evidence — The page reports a 75% reduction in tightness from clinical scoring under dermatological control in 30 volunteers with xerosis. Qualification: Duration, comparator, randomization, scale, tested formula code and full report UNKNOWN. A retained 2016 customer review is only a weak named-product existence bound.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
CV / body eligibility and formula — The US Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser page explicitly documents body as well as facial use and lists a fragrance-free formula with squalane and ceramides. Qualification: Current US INCI is reproduced. Retailer niacinamide wording is not confirmed by that INCI; a 473ml import cannot be assumed formula-identical without a label check.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
EH480 / Mercure wash — Mercure Store offers an Elemental Herbology Body Wash 480ml and describes petitgrain/lemon/neroli/bergamot-related notes; its published ingredient panel begins water, glyceryl stearate SE, shea butter, ethylhexyl palmitate and cetearyl alcohol. Qualification: The panel appears emulsion-like and may be misassigned. Exact wash formula is unresolved; do not silently replace it with a different amenity list.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Elemental Herbology 370 ml Malaysian listing limitation
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04
An opened Shopee listing by northwestsdnbhd, Selangor, identifies Elemental Herbology 370 ml Body Wash with Neroli & Bergamot Oils, shows Sold Out and RM106 after voucher. The voucher price is not a verified ordinary base price. Seller originality wording is not authentication; the 370 ml product is not established as the Mercure 480 ml formula or a particular hotel amenity.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
St Regis's European boutique did not establish an exact current Remède body-wash offer. LovelySkin and Petit Maple were discovery leads, not a verified Malaysian body-wash channel. Do not conclude discontinued or unavailable worldwide. Hotel amenity identity, formula and MY price remain UNKNOWN.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Nirvae hospitality-supplier social content was a lead; the opened NorthWest site establishes a Malaysian supplier business, not a priced and identified Nirvae body-wash SKU. No scent, formulation, ownership or MY stock conclusion is drawn from the lead.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Brand-parent relationships — Opened corporate pages associate LRP/CeraVe with L'Oréal, Dove with Unilever, Ceradan with Hyphens, Naturium with e.l.f. Beauty, and Aveeno with Kenvue. Qualification: These are group relationships, not proof of a current majority shareholder's nationality. They confer no product merit.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Avène / Pierre Fabre ownership — Pierre Fabre's governance table updated March 2026 records 86.3% foundation ownership, 9.8% employees and 3.9% treasury shares; the corporate site identifies Avène within the group. Qualification: Ownership and country of a foundation/group must not be confused with the manufacturing location of every bottle.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Diptyque / investor relationship — Manzanita's portfolio lists Diptyque and its corporate site identifies a London-based entity. Qualification: Exact current share percentage / majority ownership not disclosed in the checked pages. French brand origin does not establish French majority ownership.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Ownership and recency limits — L'Occitane group profile, Uriage ownership and earlier CeraVe review leads were blocked. The Kimberly-Clark/Kenvue transaction site used expected second-half-2026 closing language, not independently verified completion. Qualification: Do not assert completion, current controlling owner, or an exact earliest global launch from these incomplete checks.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Yukazan / Yagishi operators — Yukazan pages identify MKA Joycare Sdn Bhd. Yagishi identifies Yagishi Sdn Bhd, registration 202501011171 (1612585W), with a Malaysian business address. Qualification: Operator, registration year and Japan-formulation marketing are not launch dates, manufacturing proof or majority shareholder disclosure.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Additional contender screen — QV Dermcare Daily Wash Malaysia was identified as a further official product lead. Qualification: No completed product, price or clinical comparison. Deferred rather than dismissed as inferior or unavailable.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
Release and age limits — No exact earliest global sale date of the currently offered formulations or defensible category refresh cycle was established. Unverified release cells include unknown current-formula age. Packaging codes, image timestamps, retailer page dates and company registration years are not launches. Older name-existence bounds are reported only where dated evidence exists.
This is the limit of the completed product, history and corporate checks; it is not a claim that release dates cannot be found.
Dry-skin care context — The American Academy of Dermatology recommends gentle fragrance-free products and distinguishes fragrance-free from unscented. It advises moisturising after bathing and professional assessment when dryness persists despite care. This supports a fragrance-avoidance use case, not a brand-specific treatment promise.
Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil Malaysian reference — Official Malaysia identifies 400 ml / NART 63122-07700-30, a 53% natural-oils claim and both lightly fragranced and unperfumed versions. It reports a 119-woman sensitive-skin, two-week consumer-use study (Spain, 2017): 99% gentle cleansing, 98% protection from drying, 97% soft/smooth feeling. Full protocol, comparator and exact offered-bottle INCI were not recovered; these are brand-published perceptions.
Eucerin Malaysian seller verification — ZALORA’s embedded product data identifies seller EUCERIN MALAYSIA OFFICIAL STORE, SKU BAC21BEE348833GS-088IUT, 400 ml, price RM99.44 (reference RM113), positive quantity and no overseas shipment flag. Seller-name attribution does not independently authenticate a delivered bottle or resolve its fragrance version.
Bioderma new exact-size import offer — FrenchBeautyHub’s Malaysia/MYR page and structured variant data identify 1 L pump bottle EAN 3701129811627 at RM105.75, in stock, shipping from France. The 1 L refill EAN 3701129807330 is RM100.69, also in stock. The 200 ml price must not be assigned to 1 L; shipping/checkout totals and delivered batch were not verified. Seller INCI contains parfum.
Naturium resolved size/price mapping — ZALORA’s embedded product data identifies 500 ml simple SKU 9834DBE6508B10GS-051VPK at RM234, seller BeautyVault_MY, positive stock and no overseas-shipment flag. The separate 100 ml simple SKU is out of stock and has no price. This resolves this page’s prior size ambiguity; authorised local distribution and delivered-batch match remain unverified.
Watsons Yukazan 75 listing price condition — The checked page labels RM62.10 as Member @ 10% Off against RM69.00. The ordinary reference is RM13.80/100 ml; the displayed member offer is RM12.42/100 ml, not an unconditional discount. The ambrette/sea-salt/sage copy and damaged water/surfactant-led list remain distinct from official Fresh Fig.
Yukazan percentage audit — Fresh product-page checks and the now-readable MKA Joycare shower-oil page still do not establish the definition, numerator/denominator, assay or certification of 55/75/95. The corporate page describes the operator and self-care positioning without resolving composition percentages. The numbers are not treated as oil concentration or a hydration ladder.
Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil — Caring exact 400 ml merchandise offer RM93.00; displayed reference RM125.00; derived RM23.25/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Fragrance-free UK reference; check the supplied bottle’s ingredient panel.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash — Watsons exact 1 L merchandise offer RM127.92; displayed reference RM159.90; derived RM12.79/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. The local oat/SLES formula differs from US versions.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil — FrenchBeautyHub exact 1 L merchandise offer RM105.75; derived RM10.58/100 ml. Channel import; positive page stock evidence on the check date. France import; contains parfum; shipping is additional.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Ceradan Moisturising Wash — Watsons exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM85.00; displayed reference RM122.80; derived RM17.00/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Lipid-ratio marketing is not a comparative outcome.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser — Care to Beauty exact 473 ml merchandise offer RM111.65; derived RM23.60/100 ml. Channel import; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Imported 473 ml bottle; regional formula match unverified.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash — AA Pharmacy exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM47.90; derived RM9.58/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Brand says fragrance-free; retailer lists heliotropine.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil — KENS exact 200 ml merchandise offer RM275.00; derived RM137.50/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Exact Do Son oil; hotel-amenity match and full INCI unknown.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash — Watsons exact 550 ml merchandise offer RM15.90; derived RM2.89/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Contains perfume; no measured win over Sensitive Skin.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash — Watsons exact 550 ml merchandise offer RM15.90; derived RM2.89/100 ml. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. The checked Malaysian Sensitive Skin variant contains perfume.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil — L’Occitane MY exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM225.00; derived RM45.00/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Buy for the almond/vanilla ritual; refill costs less per volume.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international — Care to Beauty exact 400 ml merchandise offer RM68.41; displayed reference RM85.51; derived RM17.10/100 ml. Channel import; positive page stock evidence on the check date. International reference contains parfum; US claims do not transfer.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
QV Gentle Wash — Watsons exact 1.25 kg merchandise offer RM91.12; displayed reference RM107.20; derived RM7.29/100 g. Channel marketplace; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Sold as 1.25 kg; compare RM/100 g separately from RM/100 ml.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil — Care to Beauty exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM112.04; derived RM22.41/100 ml. Channel import; positive page stock evidence on the check date. C8+ is distinct from old Xémose; full supplied-bottle INCI unknown.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil — Vase official exact 330 ml merchandise offer RM58.00; derived RM17.58/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Contains parfum; manufacture claim is distinct from majority ownership.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide — Yagishi official exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM104.00; derived RM20.80/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Fragrance-free and essential-oil-scented wording conflict.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance — Yagishi official exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM74.00; derived RM14.80/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Distinct Fragrance version; full current ingredient list unknown.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell — Yukazan official exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM69.90; displayed reference RM79.90; derived RM13.98/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Advertised Bluebell; percentage meaning and relative performance unverified.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig — Yukazan official exact 500 ml merchandise offer RM69.90; displayed reference RM79.90; derived RM13.98/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Fresh Fig official formula; Watsons’ similarly named listing differs.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony — Yukazan official exact 300 ml merchandise offer RM69.90; displayed reference RM79.90; derived RM23.30/100 ml. Channel official; positive page stock evidence on the check date. Smaller bottle; higher unit cost with no proved hydration upgrade.
Positive stock comes from exact structured offer/variant data, not an Add button alone. Shipping, fulfilment and delivered batch are not guaranteed by the observation.
Yukazan size comparison — Official 55/75 are RM69.90 for 500 ml (RM13.98/100 ml); official 95 is RM69.90 for 300 ml (RM23.30/100 ml). Relative unit-cost increase is (23.30 / 13.98 − 1) × 100 = 66.666…%, displayed 66.7%. No recovered matched trial proves an offsetting hydration advantage.
A price calculation, not a measured performance comparison.
Smaller sizes and refills — Official Yukazan 55/75/95 100 ml offers each RM28.90 (reference RM33.90); trial spending is lower, unit cost higher. Vase 100 ml is RM22 versus 330 ml RM58. L’Occitane official 250 ml RM125, 500 ml RM225, 500 ml refill RM200. Aveeno 354 ml RM50.32 (reference RM62.90) versus 1 L RM127.92 (reference RM159.90). These are merchandise quotes without assumed voucher eligibility or shipping.
Yukazan adjacent washes — Relax Zen and Just Charm 500 ml each RM44.90 (reference RM51.90); Firming Fit 300 ml RM44.90 (reference RM51.90). Their scent-description / ingredient-parenthesis discrepancies remain unresolved, and no recovered finished-wash evidence demonstrates body-fat loss or firming. The current catalogue does not establish every past limited edition.
CeraVe name-existence age bound — Purchased US reviewer observation on 2023-07-27 gives 1,165 days to 2026-10-04, or at least 3 years 2 months for the named product. It does not date the current 473 ml imported formulation. The same named-US-product bound applies to US Lipikar only, not the international oil.
Calendar difference from an on-sale-by observation; no recency score can be computed.
Price scenario arithmetic — L’Occitane refill is RM40.00/100 ml against bottle RM45.00; Bioderma refill is RM10.07/100 ml against pump RM10.58; Vase trial RM22.00/100 ml against large bottle RM17.58; Aveeno 354 ml RM14.21/100 ml against 1 L RM12.79; Yukazan minis RM28.90/100 ml. Refills require an appropriate existing container. Stock is a buying filter and never changes merit.
Rounded display from unrounded merchandise-price arithmetic; no delivered-price claim.
Assessment limits — No recovered independent, matched head-to-head body-cleansing trial supports a cross-brand winner. Ingredient presence, published ordering, oil percentages, pH, marketing skin types, brand reputation and supplier claims cannot generate comparable clinical point estimates. Scent descriptions are attributed; no hands-on sniff, rinse or tolerance test was performed by Refer.
Conditional advice combines explicit shopper needs with available formula and buying evidence; it does not assert universal tolerability.
Field and scope audit — The comparison expands the inherited named candidates with QV Gentle Wash and Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil. Older surfaced candidates, unrelated Lipikar/Atoderm variants, unidentified hotel amenities, treatment washes and leave-on products remain logged with their specific evidence or scope limitation. Deferred research is not evidence of inferiority or Malaysian unavailability.
The historical candidate queue is retained in full; the present comparison is a selected field, not an exhaustive census of all Malaysian washes.
86
Aveeno Malaysian published ingredient check
ObservationRecorded 2026-10-04
Aveeno Malaysian ingredient check — The checked Watsons 354 ml and 1 L ingredient lists both include Quaternium-15. This records the published ingredient only; it does not establish the supplied batch, its concentration, an individual reaction or a comparative safety penalty. Buyers avoiding that named ingredient should check the supplied bottle rather than substituting a US formula.
Ingredient identity only; no safety ranking or supplied-batch guarantee.
Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 3005e9655b5d954d7d6e73663e5d68c1f1178026687dd9cf913985aa88ab91ab. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 0d401d3839708564e3019eafd2173745c87f85165a60cebbb4c9a62e0b398858. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 8f46604be39929ef098603dfbb3c0e3168a542bb9dde58ebbab07f7a6098f97b. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Ceradan Moisturising Wash reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 3318b970bde60912149edecebfc27b1a16fe4ead60cb77591a9b7b3b724e80c2. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Singapore reference · 500 ml · MY batch match unverified
CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 d36d903f5d3f5bad057f3636e18e07c2482a2d7183a0f7addad4a3bec1c08934. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 cf3d5aa0e509f1f51bdf087fa088ce9d602ce4f2a9aaf28c8072b952a21a2f0f. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 955c38ace1f2a927c47298b11c21460abaf7a375df6b2d0573d9811e2d92ae17. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash photo access limit — Published product image URL could not be independently inspected because the image endpoint returned HTTP 403. No similar bottle or generated package was substituted.
The product remains in the comparison. Image absence is an evidence-access limitation, not product merit.
Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 69d8bc50ba26ccc6404ee62c6454d4954a20c6e576c2c0e5ca3089e58190e8b9. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 e9f77be8f035149aff10485dbb3586941792f0485662778c2519977601990f4d. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 91058cb799471a724b563c6600e2b54e79abf9acb0b322910d55d26ef747f9ca. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash reference photo
ObservationRecorded 2026-10-04
Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 5781cfcfb09ac2237a0981c76ed32d8188f010c43bc0337c8ed4b1fc8b4c101e. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
QV Gentle Wash reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 b70d9725e14e82abfd29da9b483bbd4f8146335274366988a007acf86cecdb7e. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 3ece44e43bee85c0280e90d05ae52f2881f7be9e48ba08def84673b4628eeaaf. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 340de40f074edb38d8a06fe12be374ff39a460525154a09b6049deba346ad31c. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide reference photo
ObservationRecorded 2026-10-04
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 b92a53fc40d446788b322615a9a3152155f9af2c6b353a9148236a1b40ef3aeb. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance reference photo
ObservationRecorded 2026-10-04
Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 6d2fb03e66bb4533a269de1b1132102e4d0b03a35485b4b99e3bccd0df01167b. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Original proportions and labels retained; packaging may change.
Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 1a3b916338beaa87f9a71ba47ae38e7004e22f775eeec973400ee710709c69f8. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Official reference pack; promotional efficacy wording is not independent evidence
Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 9edb5cb91dd6baea0435380c8b7aed71711030ad666d37ece3d8b4977dd9d7b5. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Official reference pack; promotional efficacy wording is not independent evidence
Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony reference photo — Source-hosted image visually checked for named line and disclosed packaging/size. SHA256 2fbf02678cc686030922e988c6b37d0226a0ff2c092cd2403229255ea54b6817. It is reference packaging, not proof of batch identity, stock or any efficacy words printed in a promotional image.
Official reference pack; promotional efficacy wording is not independent evidence
Dove Deeply Nourishing reference-photo identity conflict
ObservationRecorded 2026-10-04
Dove Deeply Nourishing photo correction — The Malaysian retailer page titles the item Deeply Nourishing 550 ml, but its image says Beauty Nourishing 500 ml. This is an unresolved product/size match and is not published as the exact compared bottle. The Watsons exact-product image endpoint returned HTTP 403.
No similar product or generated packaging substitutes for the unverified exact reference photo.
QV Gentle Wash manufacturer SDS Version 08, issued 23 May 2025, identifies relative density approximately 1.0 g/ml. Manufacturer Ego Pharmaceuticals document is publicly hosted by Chem-Pack; its listed ingredient set aligns with the Malaysian Gentle Wash reference. This supports an approximate affordability proxy, not an exact measurement of the delivered Malaysian batch. The table retains its mass label.
Manufacturer-issued SDS, approximate density; supplied Malaysian bottle not independently measured.
L'Occitane current A26 regional ingredient reference recovered — official Saudi page identifies 29HD500A26 and an oil-led cleansing design with grape-seed oil, sweet-almond oil, TIPA-laureth sulfate and intentional fragrance. This is a current same-code reference, not a proved Malaysian supplied-bottle match. Full Malaysian INCI remains unverified; no hydration magnitude or rinse result is inferred.
Saudi same-code reference; Malaysian delivered-batch equivalence remains unknown.
Diptyque current Do Son regional ingredient reference recovered — official US DOSSHOILV2 page identifies a castor/apricot-oil cleansing design, MIPA-laureth sulfate and intentional perfume; it advises checking updated packaging. The KENS SKU ends DOSSHOILV2 but a delivered-batch match is not established. This improves the design assessment basis without proving hydration superiority, scent liking or hotel-amenity equivalence.
US DOSSHOILV2 reference; Malaysian delivered-batch equivalence remains unknown.
Uriage France current C8+ cleansing oil official reference recovered — formula 44455-29 lists sorbitol, glycerin, SLES/co-surfactants, shea-derived lipids, cholesterol and ceramides, without a listed parfum entry. The brand positions C8+ for dry skin and publishes a rinse-off instruction. Current reference design may be assessed conditionally; neither the old Xémose study nor its historical existence date is transferred to the present C8+ offer. Delivered import-batch match remains unverified.
French 44455-29 reference; old study and launch evidence are not transferred.
Yagishi current design claims — ceramide page highlights goat milk, shea butter and a ceramide positioning; the separate Fragrance page states a moisturizing goat-milk body-wash purpose. These support only conditional low-confidence design judgements, not its skin-reconstruction, healing or anti-ageing claims. Neither page supplies a complete INCI; the essential-oil versus fragrance-free label conflict remains unresolved.
Manufacturer positioning only. No complete current INCI or verified skin-reconstruction outcome.
Category selection context — AAD body-cleansing guidance favours creamy and fragrance-free-labelled cleansers in its dry-skin context. This informs Refer's low-fragrance editorial default, not a brand-specific efficacy score or the claim that fragrance irritates every user. Conditioning ingredients in a rinse-off formula do not establish equivalence to a leave-on moisturizer.
Dry-skin context informs the editorial low-fragrance default; it does not validate any brand score.
L’Occitane Almond / current Malaysian products — updated qualification
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-04, 2026-10-05
LO / current Malaysian products — Official Malaysian pages offer Almond Softening Shower Oil 250ml, 500ml and 500ml refill with A26 product codes and 'Same Formula ∣ New Look' wording; almond/vanilla and milky-foam descriptions are brand claims. Qualification: Full current Malaysian INCI did not render; the same-code Saudi reference is now recovered, with delivered-batch match unknown. See [109]. A redirected legacy URL is not evidence of discontinuation; packaging code A26 is not a verified release date.
Preserved external research observation; manufacturer claims remain attributed and are not Refer measurements.
QV Gentle Wash Malaysian formula — updated qualification
OfficialRecorded 2026-10-04, 2026-10-05
QV Gentle Wash Malaysian formula — Official Malaysia and Watsons list a fragrance/soap-free wash, 15% glycerin claim and matching ingredient sequence for 1.25 kg. It is a mass-labelled product; exact delivered-batch density is unverified. A manufacturer approximate 1.0 g/ml reference supports a labelled affordability proxy only; exact table pricing remains per 100 g. See [108, 125].
Unit-cost calculation — Exact displayed MYR merchandise price divided by the matching labelled amount and multiplied by 100. Millilitre-labelled products use RM/100 ml; QV exact table pricing uses RM/100 g; a separately labelled manufacturer-density proxy supports approximate affordability, without asserting exact bottle volume. See [125]. No currency conversion, shipping estimate, gift value, member voucher or rounded-score reconstruction is used. Calculations retain Decimal values before two-place display rounding.
Arithmetic is reproduced from exact recorded offers; unit affordability is not overall value or a clinical merit score.
Diptyque Do Son exact Malaysian offer — updated qualification
RetailerRecorded 2026-10-04, 2026-10-05
Diptyque Do Son exact Malaysian offer — KENS individual product page now identifies Do Son Shower Oil 200 ml, SKU DT-B-DOSSHOILV2 at RM275; exact variant structured data says InStock. Visible template includes both Add/Sold Out strings, so structured variant evidence is identified explicitly. Retail copy describes tuberose / oil-to-foam and apricot seed oil; supplied-bottle INCI and hotel-amenity equivalence remain unverified; a current US DOSSHOILV2 reference has now been recovered. See [110].
Uriage C8+ identity and offer — updated qualification
RetailerRecorded 2026-10-04, 2026-10-05
Uriage C8+ identity and offer — Care to Beauty’s current page identifies Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil 500 ml, RM112.04 and In stock / Ready to ship. It advertises fragrance-free formulation and C8+ technology. Full seller INCI did not render; a current French C8+ reference 44455-29 is now recovered, without proving a delivered-batch match. See [111]. This is distinct from the old Xémose regional formula; the old study and 2016 existence date are not transferred.
Assessment provenance — one announced whole-field Pareto scoring request returned HTTP 524 without an assessment or billing metadata. Its charge is UNKNOWN and no returned scores are adopted. Scores here are Codex author editorial assessments, normalized using Refer's pure ScoringService; they are not a Pareto result, clinical test or multi-model scoring panel. The required read-only independent challenge audits the finished guide separately.
On-file request failure and authored assessment records; billing metadata was not returned.
120
Cetaphil label conflict and sourced ingredient function
Cetaphil Malaysian Ultra Gentle identity: the official brand calls it fragrance-free, while AA Pharmacy’s 500 ml ingredient panel lists SLES and heliotropine. Health Canada identifies Heliotropine as a common name for piperonal and lists fragrance ingredient as its topical purpose; the European Commission background describes piperonal/heliotropin as a fragrance, fixative or masking material. This supports classifying the listed material for the editorial preference, not inferring its specific role, dose, sensed intensity, supplied-bottle match, irritation or safety. The formula-label conflict remains unresolved, so the score gets no fragrance-free fit bonus; a confirmed manufacturer/bottle correction could change it.
Dove Deeply Nourishing is assessed conditionally using Watsons’ dated 550 ml title, price and published ingredient list. A separate Pandan retailer photo says Beauty Nourishing 500 ml and is rejected as an exact identity/size match. Fresh access to the Watsons listing returned HTTP 403 on 2026-10-05; no current bottle label was recovered and no price or stock update is inferred. The listing-based design estimates remain; confidence and the buying note disclose the identity question. RM15.90/500 ml=RM3.18/100 ml as a size-only sensitivity assumption versus the quoted RM15.90/550 ml=RM2.890909…; both remain at value 100, without asserting a priced 500 ml offer.
Sensitivity methods: both design estimates plus/minus 5, bounded 0–100; scent-indifferent scenario gives cleansing design 90 for all; recorded retailer reference price substituted for dated offer, otherwise base retained. All candidate scenario results are in their assessment rows. These are assumptions, not probability estimates, measured effects or confidence intervals. Cetaphil would reach 84.3 if a matched manufacturer/bottle correction established the fragrance-free reference; Eucerin would reach 78.7 if the offered recipe were confirmed unperfumed. Neither is the base or a second measured score. QV approximate-density scenario results are recorded in [125].
Calculated from the recorded inputs. This is not a separately observed market price.
Yukazan 55 Bluebell and 75 Fresh Fig both use design 75/80 and unit cost RM13.98/100 ml; continuous affordability 70.33271278573301250277527336; overall 75.4. 95 Calm Ebony uses the same design estimates and RM23.30/100 ml, affordability 55.59340090240888917444366363; overall 71.5. Unrounded total gap 3.93048808199039399559620537 is entirely merchandise affordability. Undefined percentage names and absent comparative hydration evidence produce no performance hierarchy.
Calculated from the recorded inputs. This is not a separately observed market price.
QV proxy calculation: RM91.12/1,250 g×100=RM7.2896/100 g. Manufacturer SDS approximate 1.0 g/ml gives approximate RM7.2896/100 ml; exact delivered-bottle volume is unmeasured. Continuous value 89.12176885457399796336508256; overall 86.4. Deliberate density assumptions, not manufacturer tolerance or a confidence interval: 0.8 g/ml → RM5.8316800/100 ml, value 95.56033075232124492077147115, overall 88.1; 1.0 g/ml → RM7.2896000/100 ml, value 89.12176885457399796336508256, overall 86.4; 1.2 g/ml → RM8.7475200/100 ml, value 83.86108073789812129169669227, overall 85.0. The quoted 1.25 kg bulk pack remains the base price; a newly checked 500 g alternative is calculated separately rather than silently replacing it. Caring product 10009199EA, QV Gentle Wash 500 g: observed ordinary sale RM48.90, reference RM74.03, no voucher deduction; listed INCI aligns with the Malaysian reference. Observed offer: RM48.90/500 g → RM9.7800/100 g, approximate-density value 80.64187259419706619186876745, scenario total 84.2; Retailer reference: RM74.03/500 g → RM14.80600/100 g, approximate-density value 68.67636132603670106729554112, scenario total 81.0. Manufacturer approximate 1.0 g/ml proxy remains conditional; actual delivered volume and checkout were not measured. These are alternate-pack scenarios, not additional ranked entries; other smaller sizes remain unpriced.
Calculated from the recorded inputs. This is not a separately observed market price.
Ownership check: owner country follows majority control, not headquarters, incorporation, manufacturing country or brand origin. Avène’s French Pierre Fabre foundation control remains supported. QV’s official brand history explicitly identifies it as Australian made and owned and still family owned under Ego Pharmaceuticals; Australia is supported as the ownership country by this declaration, not inferred from manufacture alone. Other unresolved majority-country fields remain Unverified. A current Beiersdorf page establishes a maxingvest majority stake, but no unsupported ultimate owner-country inference is adopted here. These facts never affect merit, price inputs or tie treatment.
Refer formulation rubric 2.2 and explicit fragrance anchors
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05
SHOWER-OIL-2.2 provisional Refer author formulation rubric: everyday cleansing design 0.40, conditioning design 0.333333, merchandise affordability 0.266667; sum 1.000000. Clinical comparative outcomes and practical rinse tests are not claimed. Value(p)=clamp(0,100,100−20×log₂(p/5)), with unrounded dated MYR/100 ml merchandise cost p. Anchors RM5=100, RM10=80, RM20=60, RM40=40, RM80=20, RM160=0; each doubling costs 20 value points between bounds. Weights are unchanged from 2.0; continuous prices replace its cliffs after R1 and before recalculation, with no chosen winner. QV uses a disclosed approximate manufacturer-density proxy. Cetaphil follows the retrieved scent-material panel under the same low-fragrance default as other references. Recency remains exempt because cleanser launch age is not monotonic in merit, not because dates are missing. Confidence, evidence abundance, stock, channel, import and owner country do not score or break ties. R3 calibration clarification: cleansing 75 means ordinary documented daily-cleansing design with scent materials; 90 means an aligned low-fragrance reference. The 15-point subscore difference contributes 6.0 weighted points. Cleansing 50 is reserved for a documented functional mismatch beyond fragrance, not ordinary perfume or SLES. No present candidate has that documented limitation. Low fragrance is a preference rather than eligibility: affordability can outweigh it. Weights, design inputs, price slope, totals and ranks remain unchanged. Unit cost is per labelled amount, not per wash; dose and consumption rates were not measured.
Refer's author judgement under the guide's published rubric, not an independent test or market measurement.
128
Refer provisional assessment: QV Gentle Wash
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — QV Gentle Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.1. Cleansing design 90.0, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 89.12176885457399796336508256. Unrounded weighted total 86.43247473514268431489667647; displayed 86.4/100, medium confidence. Strong fit for the low-fragrance default: the Malaysian reference explicitly describes a soap-free, fragrance-free daily wash with a mixed cleansing system. This assesses design, not observed irritation. [115] The glycerin-centred humectant design supports a good conditioning assessment. The claimed 15% is not a linear score input and does not prove superior retained hydration. [115] Dated merchandise unit cost 7.289600 MYR/100 g; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 89.12176885457399796336508256. Manufacturer approximate 1.0 g/ml proxy; exact table remains per 100 g. [125, 71] Sensitivity: base 86.4; retailer reference-price substitution 85.2 (recorded=True, unit cost 8.57600, value 84.43246378183353917104001418); scent-indifferent design scenario 86.4; design minus 5 82.8, plus 5 90.1. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 90.0, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 72.89516312138234712929509625. Unrounded weighted total 82.10537446408966636192773543; displayed 82.1/100, medium confidence. The documented Malaysian fragrance-free daily-cleansing design fits the low-fragrance default. SLES is not a standalone penalty; Quaternium-15 is disclosed for shoppers already avoiding it, not assigned an unmeasured irritation score. [22, 86] Glycerin, oat and conditioning-polymer positioning support a good moisturizing design judgement. This is the local reference, without importing US formula claims or a barrier-repair result. [22] Dated merchandise unit cost 12.79200 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 72.89516312138234712929509625. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [59, 127] Sensitivity: base 82.1; retailer reference-price substitution 80.4 (recorded=True, unit cost 15.9900, value 66.45660122363510017188870765); scent-indifferent design scenario 82.1; design minus 5 78.4, plus 5 85.8. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 75.0, continuous affordability 100. Unrounded weighted total 81.6666750; displayed 81.7/100, low confidence. Same ordinary mixed-system cleansing assessment as Sensitive Skin: the Malaysian list is perfumed. Different ingredient ordering does not establish a measurable gentleness gap. [20, 21] Glycerin and the fatty-acid/lipid-related reference support the same credible moisturizing design estimate as Sensitive Skin. Do not reward the Nourishing name or ingredient ordering as an outcome. [21] Dated merchandise unit cost 2.890909090909090909090909091 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 100. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [65, 127] Sensitivity: base 81.7; retailer reference-price substitution 81.7 (recorded=False, unit cost 2.890909090909090909090909091, value 100); scent-indifferent design scenario 87.7; design minus 5 78.0, plus 5 85.3. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 75.0, continuous affordability 100. Unrounded weighted total 81.6666750; displayed 81.7/100, medium confidence. A credible ordinary mixed-system daily body cleanser, with perfume in the Malaysian list. That intentional fragrance is the trade-off for this low-fragrance default; Sensitive Skin naming is not a fragrance-free fact. [20] Glycerin and the fatty-acid/lipid-related reference support a credible moisturizing design. No finished-wash test establishes an advantage over Deeply Nourishing; both receive the same estimate. [20, 21] Dated merchandise unit cost 2.890909090909090909090909091 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 100. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [66, 127] Sensitivity: base 81.7; retailer reference-price substitution 81.7 (recorded=False, unit cost 2.890909090909090909090909091, value 100); scent-indifferent design scenario 87.7; design minus 5 78.0, plus 5 85.3. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Ceradan Moisturising Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 90.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 64.68930507274045879232506837. Unrounded weighted total 81.58380791583247992477294901; displayed 81.6/100, medium confidence. The documented fragrance-free, soap-free cleansing design fits the stated everyday default. Its sodium trideceth sulphate is not evidence of a harsh finished wash or of an all-sulfates-free recipe. [25] The triglyceride/glycerin/shea and skin-lipid reference supports a coherent emollient-plus-humectant design. This slightly higher judgement is about formulation intent; neither lipid count nor the 3:1:1 claim proves superior barrier outcomes. [25] Dated merchandise unit cost 17.00 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 64.68930507274045879232506837. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [61, 127] Sensitivity: base 81.6; retailer reference-price substitution 78.8 (recorded=True, unit cost 24.5600, value 54.07378878583815310971427063); scent-indifferent design scenario 81.6; design minus 5 77.9, plus 5 85.3. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 90.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 56.71972222949886056310969555. Unrounded weighted total 79.45858316777377264978277318; displayed 79.5/100, low confidence. The current French C8+ reference documents a rinse-off cleansing system without listed parfum; the offer is fragrance-free-labelled. Assessment is conditional on this recipe, without transferring the old product study. [118, 111] Current sorbitol/glycerin and shea-derived/lipid reference supports the same coherent conditioning tier as the other referenced low-fragrance lipid washes. C8+ or ceramide-count marketing does not raise the score. [111] Dated merchandise unit cost 22.40800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 56.71972222949886056310969555. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [72, 127] Sensitivity: base 79.5; retailer reference-price substitution 79.5 (recorded=False, unit cost 22.40800, value 56.71972222949886056310969555); scent-indifferent design scenario 79.5; design minus 5 75.8, plus 5 83.1. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 78.38684673309549921324700433. Unrounded weighted total 79.23649025777437748869893890; displayed 79.2/100, low confidence. The documented ordinary rinse-off system is credible, with parfum in both the regional reference and seller list. Fragrance is the default-fit trade-off, not proof of irritation; imports receive no penalty. [9, 54] The glycerin/glyceryl-oleate and related conditioning reference supports a coherent humectant/emollient design. Brand hydration and perception percentages are excluded from points and are not head-to-head evidence. [9, 10] Dated merchandise unit cost 10.57500 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 78.38684673309549921324700433. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [60, 127] Sensitivity: base 79.2; retailer reference-price substitution 79.2 (recorded=False, unit cost 10.57500, value 78.38684673309549921324700433); scent-indifferent design scenario 85.2; design minus 5 75.6, plus 5 82.9. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 90.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 55.65538567558661915220913774. Unrounded weighted total 79.17475973195165696946215413; displayed 79.2/100, low confidence. The UK reference supports a low-fragrance cleansing design well aligned with this default. Assessment is conditional on that reference; Caring supplied-bottle equivalence has not been established. [33, 58] Its humectant and lipid-associated reference supports a coherent conditioning design. Brand hydration figures are not converted to points, and no outcome advantage over Ceradan/CeraVe is asserted. [33, 34] Dated merchandise unit cost 23.2500 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 55.65538567558661915220913774. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [58, 127] Sensitivity: base 79.2; retailer reference-price substitution 76.9 (recorded=True, unit cost 31.2500, value 47.12287620450550608518722281); scent-indifferent design scenario 79.2; design minus 5 75.5, plus 5 82.8. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 90.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 55.21857675033843421444797999. Unrounded weighted total 79.05827720628249923666419948; displayed 79.1/100, low confidence. The documented US fragrance-free cleansing reference fits the default and explicitly permits body use. The 473 ml imported bottle has not been matched to that recipe. [37, 62] The glycerin/squalane/skin-lipid reference supports a coherent conditioning design. Ceramide counts, US reputation and unconfirmed niacinamide copy earn no bonus; rinse-off deposition is unknown. [37] Dated merchandise unit cost 23.60465116279069767441860465 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 55.21857675033843421444797999. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [62, 127] Sensitivity: base 79.1; retailer reference-price substitution 79.1 (recorded=False, unit cost 23.60465116279069767441860465, value 55.21857675033843421444797999); scent-indifferent design scenario 79.1; design minus 5 75.4, plus 5 82.7. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 81.23804877851813599536006809. Unrounded weighted total 78.33014675362109577147468328; displayed 78.3/100, low confidence. Credible ordinary cleansing design, with the same low-fragrance preference trade-off as other scent-material-containing references. The retrieved AA Pharmacy INCI lists heliotropine, identified by primary ingredient references as a fragrance material; the brand fragrance-free claim does not override that conflict. Dose, specific purpose, actual scent and supplied-bottle match remain unknown; this is no measured irritation inference. [120] The retrieved reference supports a glycerin/betaine/panthenol moisturizing design. These ingredient functions inform a good editorial assessment; retained hydration and individual comfort are unknown. [120] Dated merchandise unit cost 9.5800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 81.23804877851813599536006809. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [63, 127] Sensitivity: base 78.3; retailer reference-price substitution 78.3 (recorded=False, unit cost 9.5800, value 81.23804877851813599536006809); scent-indifferent design scenario 84.3; design minus 5 74.7, plus 5 82.0. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 64.51585539955723035619994134. Unrounded weighted total 75.53755461183372794739676976; displayed 75.5/100, low confidence. The international documented daily-cleansing reference contains parfum and has the corresponding low-fragrance-default trade-off. US fragrance-free claims are not transferred. [13, 16] Glycerin/sucrose and shea-derived conditioning design supports the coherent moisturizing tier. The US oil-plus-cream regimen is not evidence for cleanser-alone superiority. [13, 16] Dated merchandise unit cost 17.102500 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 64.51585539955723035619994134. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [69, 127] Sensitivity: base 75.5; retailer reference-price substitution 73.8 (recorded=True, unit cost 21.377500, value 58.07813707212441087122983652); scent-indifferent design scenario 81.5; design minus 5 71.9, plus 5 79.2. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 70.33271278573301250277527336. Unrounded weighted total 75.42205352043306524507757382; displayed 75.4/100, medium confidence. The supplied SLES/co-surfactant reference supports an ordinary scented cleansing design. Advertised Bluebell means absence of a Parfum entry is not a fragrance-free conclusion. [1] The documented olive/shea/glycerin conditioning design supports a good judgement. No score bonus comes from 55, listed ceramide or assumed oil concentration; no measured gap from 75 is established. [1, 57] Dated merchandise unit cost 13.9800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 70.33271278573301250277527336. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [76, 127] Sensitivity: base 75.4; retailer reference-price substitution 74.4 (recorded=True, unit cost 15.9800, value 66.47465183468220526372163046); scent-indifferent design scenario 81.4; design minus 5 71.8, plus 5 79.1. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 70.33271278573301250277527336. Unrounded weighted total 75.42205352043306524507757382; displayed 75.4/100, medium confidence. The official Fresh Fig reference supports the same ordinary scented cleansing tier as Bluebell. Watsons is a separate unresolved formula/scent identity. [2, 4] The documented shea/oil/glycerin conditioning design receives the same estimate as 55. Published ordering and the undefined 75 claim do not establish more retained hydration. [2, 57] Dated merchandise unit cost 13.9800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 70.33271278573301250277527336. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [77, 127] Sensitivity: base 75.4; retailer reference-price substitution 74.4 (recorded=True, unit cost 15.9800, value 66.47465183468220526372163046); scent-indifferent design scenario 81.4; design minus 5 71.8, plus 5 79.1. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 63.72826248461762633866657331. Unrounded weighted total 73.66086457198552856285319910; displayed 73.7/100, medium confidence. The documented ordinary mixed cleansing system is a credible scented daily wash. Parfum is the low-fragrance-default trade-off; a pleasant yuzu/tea description does not score predicted liking. [18] Glycerin/glyceryl-oleate and saccharide-isomerate positioning support a good moisturizing design judgement. No finished-product magnitude is inferred from the supplier or 24-hour claim. [18, 19] Dated merchandise unit cost 17.57575757575757575757575758 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 63.72826248461762633866657331. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [73, 127] Sensitivity: base 73.7; retailer reference-price substitution 73.7 (recorded=False, unit cost 17.57575757575757575757575758, value 63.72826248461762633866657331); scent-indifferent design scenario 79.7; design minus 5 70.0, plus 5 77.3. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 75.0, continuous affordability 68.68805648291549827765669363. Unrounded weighted total 73.31681295812962717920787752; displayed 73.3/100, low confidence. Conditional judgement of the advertised ordinary fragranced body-wash purpose, on the same scented-default scale. The unknown surfactant system is not reconstructed or called harsh. [23, 112] Conditional assessment of the advertised goat-milk moisturizing intent, on the same broad tier as the other Yagishi wash. Undisclosed chemistry does not prove inferior conditioning; full INCI and actual outcomes remain unknown. [23, 112] Dated merchandise unit cost 14.800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 68.68805648291549827765669363. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [75, 127] Sensitivity: base 73.3; retailer reference-price substitution 73.3 (recorded=False, unit cost 14.800, value 68.68805648291549827765669363); scent-indifferent design scenario 79.3; design minus 5 69.7, plus 5 77.0. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 53.72347407219204158186100253. Unrounded weighted total 72.65958266040923515251012796; displayed 72.7/100, low confidence. Conditional assessment uses the brand-described lightly fragranced version, because the offered version is unresolved. A verified unperfumed version would be a different fit scenario; pH5 positioning is not an independent assay. [52, 67] The brand-described lipid-rich oil/dexpanthenol design supports the coherent conditioning tier conditionally. Advertised 53% and consumer study percentages are not converted to points; exact offered INCI remains unknown. [52] Dated merchandise unit cost 24.8600 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 53.72347407219204158186100253. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [67, 127] Sensitivity: base 72.7; retailer reference-price substitution 71.7 (recorded=True, unit cost 28.2500, value 50.03498264944349279103548629); scent-indifferent design scenario 78.7; design minus 5 69.0, plus 5 76.3. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 80.0, continuous affordability 55.59340090240888917444366363. Unrounded weighted total 71.49156543844267124948136845; displayed 71.5/100, medium confidence. A documented oil/surfactant rinse-off design with advertised Calm Ebony scent fits the ordinary scented tier. A different surfactant name or vanillyl butyl ether presence does not establish irritation or a warming outcome. [3] Shea/oil/glycerin and lactate-associated reference supports the same broad conditioning estimate as 55/75. Neither absent listed ceramide nor the undefined 95 claim establishes worse or better retained hydration. [3, 57] Dated merchandise unit cost 23.300 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 55.59340090240888917444366363. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [78, 127] Sensitivity: base 71.5; retailer reference-price substitution 70.5 (recorded=True, unit cost 26.63333333333333333333333333, value 51.73533995135808193539002076); scent-indifferent design scenario 77.5; design minus 5 67.8, plus 5 75.2. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Medium confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 75.0, continuous affordability 58.86832943267265070687652411. Unrounded weighted total 70.69821580482251774605064205; displayed 70.7/100, low confidence. Conditional judgement of the advertised ordinary essential-oil-scented body-wash design. The full cleansing chemistry remains unknown; the simultaneous fragrance-free label is not relied on for strict avoidance. [23, 24, 112] The explicitly claimed goat-milk/shea moisturizing design supports a conditional credible emollient-intent tier. Skin reconstruction and ceramide-count claims are not credited; the unknown full formula makes application uncertain. [112] Dated merchandise unit cost 20.800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 58.86832943267265070687652411. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [74, 127] Sensitivity: base 70.7; retailer reference-price substitution 70.7 (recorded=False, unit cost 20.800, value 58.86832943267265070687652411); scent-indifferent design scenario 76.7; design minus 5 67.0, plus 5 74.4. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Provisional Refer author assessment — L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 36.60149997115375274185044224. Unrounded weighted total 68.09371719280765778241103188; displayed 68.1/100, low confidence. The current same-code Saudi reference documents an oil-based rinse-off system with intentional fragrance. It has the ordinary scented-default trade-off; exact Malaysian batch match remains unverified. [109] The current grape-seed/almond-oil conditioning design supports the coherent emollient tier. Price, luxury positioning, natural origin and advertised clinical percentages add no formulation points. [114, 109] Dated merchandise unit cost 45.00 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 36.60149997115375274185044224. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [68, 127] Sensitivity: base 68.1; retailer reference-price substitution 68.1 (recorded=False, unit cost 45.00, value 36.60149997115375274185044224); scent-indifferent design scenario 74.1; design minus 5 64.4, plus 5 71.8. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 35.46982940382640344872696635. Unrounded weighted total 67.79193799763017552846167394; displayed 67.8/100, low confidence. The official cleansing reference is a documented scented routine wash, even with no-artificial-fragrance positioning. It has the same default-fit trade-off as the other scented formulas, without an import/channel penalty. [32] The glycerin-centred humectant-plus-oil/squalane reference supports the coherent conditioning tier. Advertised glycerin percentage does not prove more hydration or count as oil concentration; no linear percentage bonus. [32] Dated merchandise unit cost 46.800 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 35.46982940382640344872696635. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [70, 127] Sensitivity: base 67.8; retailer reference-price substitution 67.8 (recorded=False, unit cost 46.800, value 35.46982940382640344872696635); scent-indifferent design scenario 73.8; design minus 5 64.1, plus 5 71.5. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Refer provisional assessment: Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-04
Provisional Refer author assessment — Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil; SHOWER-OIL-2.2. Cleansing design 75.0, conditioning design 85.0, continuous affordability 4.37280572950680791860635047. Unrounded weighted total 59.49938798547039194723099966; displayed 59.5/100, low confidence. The current US DOSSHOILV2 reference documents an oil-to-emulsion perfumed rinse-off cleanser. Same ordinary scented-default tier; fragrance-house prestige and predicted scent liking do not earn points. [110] The castor/apricot-oil design supports the same coherent emollient tier as the other referenced oils. Conditioning outcomes, sensory superiority and KENS delivered-batch equivalence remain unknown. [110] Dated merchandise unit cost 137.500 MYR/100 ml; continuous affordability 100 − 20 × log₂(p/5), bounded 0–100, gives 4.37280572950680791860635047. Exact quoted pack, no member voucher or shipping estimate. [64, 127] Sensitivity: base 59.5; retailer reference-price substitution 59.5 (recorded=False, unit cost 137.500, value 4.37280572950680791860635047); scent-indifferent design scenario 65.5; design minus 5 55.8, plus 5 63.2. All criteria covered; pure Refer ScoringService normalization; no clinical trial or availability penalty. Stress scenarios are editorial assumptions, not observed effects. Reconfirmed after the explicit 2.2 calibration wording; no numerical input or total changed.
Low confidence; documented design judgement, not comparative clinical performance.
Cleansing and foaming oil exclusions from the current field
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-10
Scope correction: remove Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil, Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil, La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international and CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser. The active ranking has 17 products. Exclusion is editorial scope, not an adverse formulation, stock or clinical judgement. Existing scores, price dates, rubric weights and historical evidence are retained.
Refer's author judgement under the guide's published rubric, not an independent test or market measurement.
150
Historical base and sensitivity orders before the scope correction
CalculationRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-10
HISTORICAL FULL FIELD, before the 10 October scope correction. These positions are archived and do not apply to the current ranking. Previously published base-order record: Derived 2.1 order: 1: QV Gentle Wash 86.4; 2: Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash 82.1; =3: Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash 81.7; =3: Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash 81.7; 5: Ceradan Moisturising Wash 81.6; 6: Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil 79.5; 7: Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil 79.2; 8: Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil 79.2; 9: CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser 79.1; 10: Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash 78.3; 11: La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international 75.5; =12: Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell 75.4; =12: Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig 75.4; 14: Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil 73.7; 15: Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance 73.3; 16: Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil 72.7; 17: Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony 71.5; 18: Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide 70.7; 19: L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil 68.1; 20: Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash 67.8; 21: Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil 59.5. Order is from unrounded complete weighted totals; exact ties share competition ranks, alphabetical within a tie for presentation only. Rounded similar values do not prove clinical differences. Both qualitative criteria moved by 5 points change an unbounded total by 3.666665 (about 3.7). Confidence and availability never break ties. Previously published weaker-price-slope record: Weaker price preference sensitivity: retain all design inputs and weights, substitute value=clamp(0,100,100−10×log₂(p/5)) for the base slope 20. Same dated quoted packs, QV approximate density unchanged; not new facts or measured effects. QV Gentle Wash: value 94.56088442728699898168254128, unrounded total 87.88290736757134215744833824, displayed 87.9, rank 1; Ceradan Moisturising Wash: value 82.34465253637022939616253418, unrounded total 86.29190645791623996238647450, displayed 86.3, rank 2; Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash: value 86.44758156069117356464754812, unrounded total 85.71935723204483318096386771, displayed 85.7, rank 3; Uriage Xémose C8+ Anti-Itch Cleansing Oil: value 78.35986111474943028155484777, unrounded total 85.22929408388688632489138659, displayed 85.2, rank 4; Avène XeraCalm A.D Cleansing Oil: value 77.82769283779330957610456887, unrounded total 85.08738236597582848473107707, displayed 85.1, rank 5; CeraVe Hydrating Foaming Oil Cleanser: value 77.60928837516921710722398999, unrounded total 85.02914110314124961833209974, displayed 85.0, rank 6; Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil: value 89.19342336654774960662350217, unrounded total 82.11824762888718874434946945, displayed 82.1, rank 7; Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash: value 100, unrounded total 81.6666750, displayed 81.7, rank =8; Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash: value 100, unrounded total 81.6666750, displayed 81.7, rank =8; Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash: value 90.61902438925906799768003405, unrounded total 80.83174337681054788573734164, displayed 80.8, rank 10; La Roche-Posay Lipikar AP+ Cleansing Oil — international: value 82.25792769977861517809997067, unrounded total 80.26877980591686397369838488, displayed 80.3, rank 11; Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell: value 85.16635639286650625138763668, unrounded total 79.37769676021653262253878691, displayed 79.4, rank =12; Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig: value 85.16635639286650625138763668, unrounded total 79.37769676021653262253878691, displayed 79.4, rank =12; Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil: value 76.86173703609602079093050127, unrounded total 78.82979383020461757625506398, displayed 78.8, rank 14; Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil: value 81.86413124230881316933328665, unrounded total 78.49710228599276428142659955, displayed 78.5, rank 15; Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance: value 84.34402824145774913882834682, unrounded total 77.49174397906481358960393876, displayed 77.5, rank 16; Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony: value 77.79670045120444458722183182, unrounded total 77.41245271922133562474068423, displayed 77.4, rank 17; L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil: value 68.30074998557687637092522112, unrounded total 76.54686109640382889120551594, displayed 76.5, rank 18; Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash: value 67.73491470191320172436348318, unrounded total 76.39597149881508776423083697, displayed 76.4, rank 19; Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide: value 79.43416471633632535343826206, unrounded total 76.18244540241125887302532103, displayed 76.2, rank 20; Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil: value 52.18640286475340395930317524, unrounded total 72.24969649273519597361549983, displayed 72.2, rank 21. This shows how strongly the authored affordability preference affects the order, without changing the base rubric.
Archived 21-product field from 5 October 2026. These former positions are historical and are not the current ranking.
Current scoped oil-format choice: no confirmed fragrance-free-labelled shower oil remains in the ranked field. QV, Aveeno and Ceradan remain fragrance-free-labelled wash choices; Bioderma is a fragranced shower oil and Eucerin’s offered fragrance version remains unverified. The four named cleansing/foaming oil entries are excluded by explicit requested scope, not a formulation or body-use verdict.
Calculated from the recorded inputs. This is not a separately observed market price.
Ceradan reader-label correction — Body wash is the active broad format label for Ceradan Moisturising Wash, replacing the earlier creamy-wash presentation under the user’s explicit instruction. Creamy describes texture; the face/body rinse-off identity and fragrance-free-labelled formula remain as previously evidenced. This is a wording change only; product identity, formula assessment, scores, prices, order and eligibility are unchanged. Original [122] is retained as the dated presentation record.
Refer's author judgement under the guide's published rubric, not an independent test or market measurement.
Yukazan Indonesian olive-oil percentage claim and regional matching limit
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-10
Yukazan percentage cross-market qualification — Yukazan Indonesia Flagship Store's Blibli Nourishing Shower Oil 95% listing explicitly claims 95% premium olive oil from Spain plus Meadowfoam seed oil. The checked Malaysian Rejuvenation / Calm Ebony page still does not define the percentage quantitatively; its published ingredient list begins shea butter then olive oil and does not name Meadowfoam. The Indonesian marketing claim supports olive oil as a possible intended meaning, but does not establish the composition, denominator or exact regional-formula equivalence of the ranked Malaysian bottle. No corresponding 55/75 measurement or hydration hierarchy is established. The 4 October Malaysian-page audit [57] remains a valid dated observation.
Indonesian flagship marketing is not verified concentration evidence for the MY Rejuvenation bottle. The MY percentage audit remains qualified.
Vase and Yukazan current advertised aroma profiles
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-10
Current manufacturer aroma descriptions — Vase Midnight Shikoku advertises Japanese Yuzu Green Tea / ryoku-cha aroma. Yukazan MY calls 55 Bluebell fresh/floral, 75 Fresh Fig clean/airy, and 95 Calm Ebony warm/woody. These are brand scent descriptions, not physical sensory tests, ingredient-concentration findings, longevity estimates or fragrance-free claims. No unlisted detailed note pyramid is imported from the Indonesian Calm Ebony listing to the Malaysian entry.
Manufacturer descriptions checked 10 October 2026, not Refer smell tests or fragrance-strength measurements.
Compact scent-profile classification and unknown-note limits
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-10
Compact scent-profile facet for the current field — QV, Aveeno and Ceradan: None added, following fragrance-free labels without promising no raw-material odour. Dove Deeply, Dove Sensitive, Bioderma and Yagishi Fragrance: Not specified, meaning no sufficiently specific supported note profile in this comparison, not scentlessness. Cetaphil, Eucerin and Yagishi Ceramide: Unverified, retaining their label/version conflicts. Yukazan 55: Floral · bluebell; Yukazan 75: Airy · fig; Vase: Citrus · green tea; Yukazan 95: Warm · woody; L'Occitane: Almond · vanilla; Naturium: Coconut · vanilla; Diptyque Do Son: Tuberose · floral. Labels condense attributed brand descriptions. The separate scent-label field and all existing bottle qualifications remain; neither this facet nor personal taste changes scores, price inputs, scope or merit order.
Profiles condense brand descriptions. None added follows fragrance-free labelling and does not promise odourlessness. Not specified means the notes are insufficiently established here. Unverified retains label/version conflicts. Scent preference does not change merit scores.
Fresh aromatic and woody aromatic shopping directions
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-10
Scent-choice interpretation — Fresh aromatic is an editorial shopping label for fresh citrus, tea or herbal directions; woody aromatic is useful for a wood/herb spa direction. Spa alone is not a fixed note family. Vase's advertised yuzu/green-tea profile shares citrus direction with Plant Origins Citrus Breeze, while Wild Wood occupies a different herbal/woody direction. None of the three MY Yukazan descriptions establishes a Vase scent match: 55 is floral, 75 is airy fig, and 95 is warm woody. 75 is a possible airy alternative and 95 a possible warm-wood alternative to sample, not demonstrated dupes or blind-buy recommendations. Almond/vanilla is a different shopping direction. No physical smell comparison, strength or persistence test was performed.
Editorial comparison of advertised directions, not measured matching, dupes, longevity or blind-buy advice.
Do Son tuberose aroma from the official product page
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-10
Diptyque Do Son aroma reference corrected — The current official DOSSHOILV2 page advertises tuberose, orange blossom and jasmine and describes the shower oil's floral character. This supports the compact Tuberose · floral profile and existing tuberose-ritual prose. [44] is an ownership/investor source, not scent evidence, and is removed from those scent claims while remaining available for the ownership claim. This is not a supplied-bottle ingredient match or a sensory test.
Official DOSSHOILV2 scent description corrects the earlier ownership-source citation; supplied-bottle formula matching remains unverified.
Existing low-fragrance and scent-indifferent winners disclosed together
CalculationRecorded 2026-10-05, 2026-10-10
Existing scent-preference scenario repeated in the short verdict — Under the SHOWER-OIL-2.2 base, QV leads at displayed 86.4. The already-recorded scent-indifferent scenario gives all entries cleansing design 90: both Dove entries become 87.7 and lead, while QV is unchanged. This is the existing assumed preference scenario, not a new base score or a measured performance finding. Its prominence is increased because readers choosing scents should see that the default favours fragrance-free labelling. Scores, inputs, weights, prices and canonical ranks remain unchanged.
Dove 87.7 is an assumed preference scenario, not a revised base score or physical performance result.
Scent style and notes are separate shopping facets
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-10
Spa / aromatic is an editorial shared shopping style for Vase Midnight Shikoku and Plant Origins Citrus Breeze / Wild Wood. Vase explicitly advertises a Japanese-inspired spa ritual; Signature Market presents its citrus and herb/wood washes in a spa-at-home routine. Citrus/tea and herbal/wood remain different directions inside the shared style. Spa is not asserted to be a standardized perfume family, an identical smell or an ingredient recipe. Scent notes retain advertised detail; style and personal liking earn no merit points.
Editorial grouping based on manufacturer descriptions; no physical smell test.
Plant Origins Citrus Breeze formula and dated price references
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-10
Exact Body Wash, 500 ml: anonymous Signature Market page shows crossed-out RM90 RRP and RM39.90 explicitly labelled Member, with an enabled add-to-cart offer. No ordinary non-member checkout quote is established. Advertised lemon, sweet orange and grapefruit; full published ingredient panel includes ALS/ALES, betaine, glycerine, aloe, decyl glucoside, butylene glycol, citrus peel oils and menthol. Ingredient spelling and full panel are preserved in SOURCE_OBSERVATIONS.json. Moisturizing/restored-barrier language is manufacturer positioning, not a Refer outcome. RRP and member price are distinct price bases.
Primary product page retrieved 10 October 2026; supplied batch and ordinary checkout price unverified.
Plant Origins Wild Wood formula and dated price references
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-10
Exact Body Wash, 500 ml: anonymous Signature Market page shows crossed-out RM90 RRP and RM39.90 explicitly labelled Member, with an enabled add-to-cart offer. No ordinary non-member checkout quote is established. Advertised lavender, clary sage and cedarwood; full published panel uses the same ALS/ALES/betaine/glucoside and glycerine/aloe/butylene-glycol design with its different essential oils and menthol. Full panel is preserved in SOURCE_OBSERVATIONS.json. Musky-floral / sweet-woody and moisturizing descriptions are manufacturer positioning, not Refer sensory or hydration results.
Primary product page retrieved 10 October 2026; supplied batch and ordinary checkout price unverified.
Both exact 500 ml primary pages claim Country of Origin: Malaysia and provide enabled buying offers on 10 October 2026. Availability is recorded official / in_stock true from those pages, without a transaction or physical stock inspection. Manufacture origin is not evidence of current majority owner country; majority-country ownership, earliest global release date of the current formula and derived age remain Unverified. None of those unknowns, membership access or sales channel changes merit points or breaks a tie.
Brand page buying facts; ownership and release evidence unresolved.
Citrus Breeze and Wild Wood each have a matched 500 ml primary product-page reference photo, retrieved and visually inspected on 10 October 2026. Labels identify the exact variants and volume. Original JPEGs and hashes are recorded in PHOTO_PROVENANCE.json; no crop, recolouring, generated packaging or formula/stock proof is asserted. These photos show reference packaging, not the supplied batch.
The user explicitly requested adding both Plant Origins Citrus Breeze and Wild Wood to the scored ranking and comparing them with Vase within a shared scent style. Both are body washes, so the four previously excluded cleansing/foaming oil entries remain excluded. The guide stays a general-category ranking; personal fit is a separate shopping facet. Historical S06 scent-reference-only status is retained as the prior dated state, superseded for current treatment by the two completed provisional assessments. No availability or member-access merit criterion is introduced.
User-authorized scope; the public update still requires the existing final approval step.
Historical S06 positions and Plant scent-reference treatment
ResearchRecorded 2026-10-10
Historical pre-extension S06 records, published earlier on 10 October 2026, not current positions or current Plant treatment. historical record 603: Current derived SHOWER-OIL-2.2 order after the explicit scope exclusions: QV Gentle Wash: 86.4/100, rank 1; Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash: 82.1/100, rank 2; Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash: 81.7/100, rank =3; Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash: 81.7/100, rank =3; Ceradan Moisturising Wash: 81.6/100, rank 5; Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil: 79.2/100, rank 6; Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash: 78.3/100, rank 7; Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell: 75.4/100, rank =8; Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig: 75.4/100, rank =8; Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil: 73.7/100, rank 10; Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance: 73.3/100, rank 11; Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil: 72.7/100, rank 12; Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony: 71.5/100, rank 13; Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide: 70.7/100, rank 14; L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil: 68.1/100, rank 15; Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash: 67.8/100, rank 16; Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil: 59.5/100, rank 17. Order uses unchanged unrounded complete weighted totals; exact ties share competition ranks and alphabetical tie presentation has no merit meaning. Rounded close values are not clinical differences; confidence and availability never break ties.; historical record 604: Current weaker-price-preference sensitivity on the same scoped field: preserve all design inputs and weights, replace value with clamp(0,100,100−10×log₂(p/5)). Same dated quoted packs and approximate QV density; a preference scenario, not measured effects. QV Gentle Wash: value 94.56088442728699898168254128, unrounded total 87.88290736757134215744833824, displayed 87.9, rank 1; Ceradan Moisturising Wash: value 82.34465253637022939616253418, unrounded total 86.29190645791623996238647450, displayed 86.3, rank 2; Aveeno Skin Relief Body Wash: value 86.44758156069117356464754812, unrounded total 85.71935723204483318096386771, displayed 85.7, rank 3; Bioderma Atoderm Shower Oil: value 89.19342336654774960662350217, unrounded total 82.11824762888718874434946945, displayed 82.1, rank 4; Dove Deeply Nourishing Body Wash: value 100, unrounded total 81.6666750, displayed 81.7, rank =5; Dove Sensitive Skin Body Wash: value 100, unrounded total 81.6666750, displayed 81.7, rank =5; Cetaphil Ultra Gentle Body Wash: value 90.61902438925906799768003405, unrounded total 80.83174337681054788573734164, displayed 80.8, rank 7; Yukazan 55% Purification Shower Oil — Bluebell: value 85.16635639286650625138763668, unrounded total 79.37769676021653262253878691, displayed 79.4, rank =8; Yukazan 75% Hydrating Shower Oil — Fresh Fig: value 85.16635639286650625138763668, unrounded total 79.37769676021653262253878691, displayed 79.4, rank =8; Eucerin pH5 Shower Oil: value 76.86173703609602079093050127, unrounded total 78.82979383020461757625506398, displayed 78.8, rank 10; Vase Creation Midnight Shikoku Shower Oil: value 81.86413124230881316933328665, unrounded total 78.49710228599276428142659955, displayed 78.5, rank 11; Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Fragrance: value 84.34402824145774913882834682, unrounded total 77.49174397906481358960393876, displayed 77.5, rank 12; Yukazan 95% Rejuvenation Shower Oil — Calm Ebony: value 77.79670045120444458722183182, unrounded total 77.41245271922133562474068423, displayed 77.4, rank 13; L’Occitane Almond Softening Shower Oil: value 68.30074998557687637092522112, unrounded total 76.54686109640382889120551594, displayed 76.5, rank 14; Naturium The Glow Getter Multi-Oil Hydrating Body Wash: value 67.73491470191320172436348318, unrounded total 76.39597149881508776423083697, displayed 76.4, rank 15; Yagishi Pure Goat’s Milk Body Wash with Ceramide: value 79.43416471633632535343826206, unrounded total 76.18244540241125887302532103, displayed 76.2, rank 16; Diptyque Do Son Shower Oil: value 52.18640286475340395930317524, unrounded total 72.24969649273519597361549983, displayed 72.2, rank 17.; historical record 611: Plant Origins scent references — Signature Market's Citrus Breeze Body Wash is advertised with lemon, sweet orange and grapefruit notes; Wild Wood Body Wash is advertised with lavender, clary sage and cedarwood, described as musky-floral / sweet-woody. These exact pages call the products body washes. They are scent references outside the scored field: complete comparative formulation, quoted-offer and score assessments are not undertaken here, so no merit position is fabricated. This is not a claim of inferior quality or unavailability.
Preserves the exact earlier public claims; use current order and the added actual-offer assessments for current advice.
Independent review correctly rejected treating crossed-out RRP as a verified purchase cost. Version 2.3 adopts current explicitly labelled offers as conditional price inputs; Member eligibility remains visible and earns no points. This is an agent-set pricing assumption under standing rubric authority after the optional preference question remained unanswered, not a claim of user approval. The qualitative anchors, weights 0.40 / 0.333333 / 0.266667 and continuous value formula are unchanged. All original 17 numerical inputs and scores remain unchanged; only the two added prices/totals and derived positions move. RRP remains a hypothetical reference-price scenario. Availability/stock/member access never adds points or breaks a tie.
Declared conditional price basis; no membership or stock criterion.
Both exact 500 ml current primary pages quote RM39.90 explicitly labelled Member, retrieved 10 October 2026. Merchandise cost = RM7.98/100 ml; continuous affordability = 86.51078696879482521843461209. Membership eligibility and current checkout terms remain conditions to verify; no assertion that all shoppers qualify. RM90 is crossed-out RRP, retained only for a hypothetical reference scenario. No voucher/shipping amount or stock bonus enters the price score. Wild Wood also has a current RM39.90 ordinary retailer listing at Calmerscapes, marked out of stock; that does not establish an ordinary Citrus Breeze offer or alter either design assessment.
Current primary Member quotes; buying condition explicit, ordinary non-member checkout price unresolved.
Refer provisional assessment — Citrus Breeze, actual offer
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-10
SHOWER-OIL-2.3: unchanged cleansing 75 and conditioning 75, affordability 86.51078696879482521843461209, unrounded overall 78.06954702860760965652430270, displayed 78.1/100. Conditional on published primary formula and RM39.90 Member quote. Scented ordinary daily design and credible glycerine/aloe humectant design retain the original anchors, with no sulfate, extract-count or natural-origin bonus/penalty. No measured scent-quality, hydration, tolerability or rinse-feel advantage is asserted. Low confidence; normalization and arithmetic use Refer pure service.
Provisional Refer formulation judgement; current Member price is conditional.
Refer provisional assessment — Wild Wood, actual offer
JudgementRecorded 2026-10-10
SHOWER-OIL-2.3: unchanged cleansing 75 and conditioning 75, affordability 86.51078696879482521843461209, unrounded overall 78.06954702860760965652430270, displayed 78.1/100. Same supported design and price inputs as Citrus Breeze; exact tie retained. Different advertised essential-oil notes do not establish a formulation, observed hydration or scent-quality win. Low confidence; conditional primary formula and RM39.90 Member quote, normalized through Refer pure service.
Provisional Refer formulation judgement; current Member price is conditional.
Both Plant variants under the same 75/75 design: current RM39.90 Member basis gives 78.1. Hypothetical RM90 RRP reference gives 71.8; it is not a non-member checkout quote. Setting cleansing design to 90 gives 84.1 at the Member basis. Moving both qualitative estimates together by minus/plus 5 gives 74.4 / 81.7. Weaker price slope gives 79.9. All are conditional preference/price/assessment scenarios, not observations or statistical intervals. RRP-to-offer difference reflects actual price evidence, not a sensory or hydration upgrade.
Reproduced hypothetical scenarios; canonical Member price condition remains explicit.
The grouped trio uses the same general provisional formulation-and-price totals: Citrus Breeze and Wild Wood both 78.1, group rank =1 at RM39.90 Member; Vase 73.7, group rank 3 at RM58/330 ml. Price inputs give Plant the higher total despite its authored conditioning estimate 75 versus Vase 80; no measured hydration or scent quality is inferred. Citrus Breeze is the closest advertised citrus direction to try for a shopper who likes Vase’s yuzu/tea; Wild Wood is the herbal/wood branch. A shopper already pleased with Vase has a known individual scent fit. No smell match, projection, longevity or post-wash-feel comparison was performed.
Conditional merit comparison and separate taste advice; individual liking remains unknown for untried products.
The first S07 preparation used a hypothetical RM90 RRP basis: both Plant totals 71.8, overall rank =13, group rank =2 behind Vase 73.7; the member-price scenario was 78.1. Those were exact calculations on a disclosed reference assumption, not verified ordinary purchase costs. The independent reviewer rejected that canonical price choice. The reviewed files, complete original source rows, arithmetic, sealed prompt and raw reply remain preserved; current actual-offer scores and positions replace the canonical use while RRP remains an explicit hypothetical scenario.
Historical preparation only; never published live or adopted as the current ranking.
Fresh primary recheck: the Cetaphil MY brand page calls Ultra Gentle Body Wash fragrance-free. The same AA Pharmacy 500 ml RM47.90 page calls it fragrance-free in prose while listing heliotropine in its ingredient panel. These visible pages do not establish two distinct supplied SKUs, a current bottle panel or the ingredient's exact dose/purpose. The existing 78.3 assessment follows the retrieved scent-material panel conditionally; 84.3 remains the existing assumption if the low-fragrance reference is established. No base input, total or position is changed by this check.
Clarify the display label to Daily low-fragrance fit for the existing cleansing-design criterion, retaining its key, anchors, 0.40 weight, full-field inputs and totals. In this documented ordinary-body-wash field the same preference uses 75 for scented references and 90 for aligned low-fragrance references, a 6.0-point weighted difference. It is a declared design/preference tier, not observed cleansing efficacy, tolerability, scent liking or a measured difference between adjacent ranks. The purpose, weights and continuous price formula are unchanged; exact ordinal ranks remain required and close scores remain weak distinctions.
Declared preference/design tier; no numerical assessment change.
:format(webp)/https://static-my.zacdn.com/p/eucerin-6620-8424093-1.jpg)
:format(webp)/https://static-my.zacdn.com/p/naturium-0867-5978792-1.jpg)
